Most overrated

The only good thing about this film is that it's based on the most amazing, most complex, most beautiful graphic novel of all times.
Thus the story is great, the characters are amazing (especially Rorschach) and the setting and feeling that you get all the way through the film are impressive.

Even so, the pathetic extra-use of slow-motion technique for the fighting sequences, the useless gore violence and the ridiculously long sex scene make what could have been the best film based on a comic book an only average, sometimes flashily adaptation.
I wish I hadn't seen it, and now I just want to go back and read the comic book again and again.

Let me quote someone else: "crude teen sex "comedy" masquerading as an art film", that's exactly what this film is.

This film was a real disappointment from Sean Penn, one of my favourite actors, but evidently not as good as director. Boring.

Una specie di American History X all'inglese...mal riuscito e decisamente troppo sopravvalutato. La scelta di un protagonista 11enne, poi, non l'ho proprio capita, e mi sembra che non c'azzecchi proprio niente. Insomma, scarso.

Sorry, this is really not my genre.

Worst homage you could think for the great Leone classic. Don't waste your time with it.