Battle for Haditha (2007)
-
67% of critics liked it
(30 reviews) -
71% of users liked it
(2,823 ratings)
The fate of two cultures becomes locked on a tragic collision course in director Nick Broomfield's dramatization of the events that led to the massacre of 24 Iraqi men, women, and children by American Marines. A squadron of American soldiers goes speeding across the Iraqi desert in a convoy of… More The fate of two cultures becomes locked on a tragic collision course in director Nick Broomfield's dramatization of the events that led to the massacre of 24 Iraqi men, women, and children by American Marines. A squadron of American soldiers goes speeding across the Iraqi desert in a convoy of armored Humvees, eventually stopping at a local store where the soldiers jump out to stretch and browse the DVD selection. Meanwhile, as the Marines strike up a conversation with the young male clerk behind the counter, two Iraqi men climb into the back of a pick-up truck to get a crash course in IED mechanics. Both the Marines and the Iraqis are simply going about their daily business as usual, just doing their best to survive in a land where war is just another fact of life. For the Marines it's all about patrolling the desert and waiting for the next bomb to go off. When a roadside IED kills one Marine and wounds two others, the vengeance with which the American soldiers strike back at the locals may cause even the most hard-line warhawks to take pause and consider the true cost of a war which has no end in sight. ~ Jason Buchanan, Rovi
- Rating, Runtime
- R, 1 hr. 33 min.
- Directed By
- Nick Broomfield
- Genres
- Art House & International, Drama
- In Theaters
- Dec 14, 2007 Wide
- On DVD
- Dec 30, 2008
- Studio
- HanWay Films
Critic Reviews
-
Steven Rea, Philadelphia Inquirer
Lacking in subtlety and nuance, Broomfield's nerve-jangling movie nonetheless succeeds in showing the war from various vantage points. And from wherever one's standing, the view is profoundly disturbing.
-
Stanley Kauffmann, New Republic
Films about the Iraq war continue to come and, I hope, will keep coming. Among the most recent, The Battle for Haditha is especially notable.
-
Andrew O'Hehir, Salon.com
It might just be the movie this war has been waiting for.
-
Manohla Dargis, New York Times
In Battle for Haditha the British filmmaker Nick Broomfield revisits a wretched chapter of the war in Iraq.
-
J. R. Jones, Chicago Reader
The killing of 24 Iraqi civilians by U.S. marines in November 2005 is still so clouded by cover-up that the last thing anyone needs now is an improvised drama about the tragedy by UK gonzo documentarian Nick Broomfield.
-
Kyle Smith, New York Post
This film by Nick Broomfield, which superficially resembles Brian De Palma's Redacted in that it is a mockumentary based on real, horrible events, is a 90-minute libel against the Marine Corps.
-
Leo Goldsmith, indieWIRE
A bold effort to grapple with what truth lies behind these images, rather than to simply throw one's hands up in the face of them
-
Brian Gibson, Vue Weekly (Edmonton, Canada)
Knuckle-whiteningly up-close and personal, lurching us into the chaos and senselessness of ideals-inspired murder; whether for religion, patriotism, money, or revenge, the results remain simply brutal.
-
Kam Williams, NewsBlaze
What's next, a picture suggesting that we have to excuse the Abu Ghraib atrocities, too, as reasonable interrogation tactics?
-
Cynthia Fuchs, PopMatters
Unable or unwilling to acknowledge or comprehend this trauma, the U.S. command structure is indicted no matter what it says.
-
Ron Wilkinson, Monsters and Critics
Previous films such as "Gunners Palace" and the more famous "War Tapes" gave us intimate footage of the day to day danger and tedium of the war, but no film has shown both sides with the power and accuracy of "Battle for Haditha"
-
Jeffrey M. Anderson, Combustible Celluloid
Broomfield very effectively balances these storylines with superb cutting.
-
Kam Williams, NewsBlaze
Remember when your mother warned that playing video games would desensitize you to violence? Now witness Exhibit A: a docudrama showcasing Generation Kill's all volunteer army in all its glory.
-
Edward Douglas, ComingSoon.net
There's a size and scope to the film we haven't seen in Broomfield's prior work that shows him capable of creating a piece of cinema on par with Michael Winterbottom's films.
-
Nathan Rabin, AV Club
Unsubtle but gripping, Battle For Haditha illustrates how a military that treats every man, woman, and child as a potential enemy can soon find that such thinking constitutes a self-fulfilling prophecy.
-
James Christopher, Times [UK]
I can't begin to describe how creepy this futuristic movie is.
-
Ken Fox, TV Guide's Movie Guide
If Broomfield hoped to shed some light on what happened at Haditha beyond our worst preconceptions, he's failed.
-
Armond White, New York Press
Although Battle for Haditha is certainly a plotted and arranged fiction, it is skillful and informative without corrupting our perspective via the techno-faddishness that undoes current filmmakers
Critic ratings and reviews powered by RottenTomatoes.com
Fresh (60% or more critics rated the movie positively)
Rotten (59% or fewer critics rated the movie positively)
Featured Audience Ratings
-
Cynthia S
This film apparently pissed off every Marine out there. Any movie that inspires THAT much emotion is noteworthy....but this is a gut wrenching film! This movie did a good job of showing all sides of this tragic circumstance, in my opinion. I felt horrible for everyone involved...and I… More
This film apparently pissed off every Marine out there. Any movie that inspires THAT much emotion is noteworthy....but this is a gut wrenching film! This movie did a good job of showing all sides of this tragic circumstance, in my opinion. I felt horrible for everyone involved...and I was left sickened to the core. -
Jani H
A modern warfare movie about a terrible massacre of Iragi people. Nick Broomfield is better known for his documents then movies. "Battle for Haditha" has a documentary feeling, focusing on the Marines as well as the Iraqi insurgents and locals. Based on a true story where… More
A modern warfare movie about a terrible massacre of Iragi people. Nick Broomfield is better known for his documents then movies. "Battle for Haditha" has a documentary feeling, focusing on the Marines as well as the Iraqi insurgents and locals. Based on a true story where 24 innocent local Iraqs were killed, "Haditha" portrays well the madness of today. Innocent people suffer because of war. It feels realistic and it is not a joy to watch it. If you think of it as a normal war movie, "Haditha" doesn't stand out. It's slowpaced but because of its story, people interested about the Irag war should see it. -
Gordon A
Believably brutal study of a military engagement gone horrifically wrong. Did make me wonder how often this must happen and it is simply covered up. -
Sarah G
<u>Director:</u>Nick Broomfield <u>Released:</u> 2008 <u>Stars:</u>Elliot Ruiz, Yasmine Hanani, Andrew McLaren <u>Genre:</u> Drama, War <u>Country:</u> UK <BR> <a… More
<u>Director:</u>Nick Broomfield <u>Released:</u> 2008 <u>Stars:</u>Elliot Ruiz, Yasmine Hanani, Andrew McLaren <u>Genre:</u> Drama, War <u>Country:</u> UK <BR> <a href="http://s137.photobucket.com/albums/q202/sarah88_uk/?action=view¤t=_09.jpg" target="_blank"><img src="http://i137.photobucket.com/albums/q202/sarah88_uk/_09.jpg" border="0" alt="Photobucket"></a> <BR> An investigation of the massacre of 24 men, women and children in Haditha, Iraq allegedly shot by 4 U.S. Marines in retaliation for the death of a U.S. Marine killed by a roadside bomb. The movie follows the story of the Marines of Kilo Company, an Iraqi family, and the insurgents who plant the roadside bomb. Now weirdly I've always been familar with Brit director Nick Broomfield but never bothered to watch any of his work. I was lucky enough to spot it on TV here in the UK and sat and watched it all the way through. I have to admit I thought it was absolutly superb indeed. As everyone knows, The Iraq war was incredibly unpopular both here and in the US, but seeing it from a soldier's point of view is something new entirely. What is done so well is that, asides dramtising the events on screen, the sodliers are characterised so well that you begin to understand them and idenitfy with them so to speak. In particular the character of Cpl. Ramirez is exactly the type of character you would expect in the marines but you see a different side to him entirely. For instance towards the end of the film he describes the horrors that he has seen during his dreams and that he can not sleep. He discusses this with one solider who didn't seem to understand him at all. Gradually as the film progresses, the marines are a unit and practically a family and ultimatly that leads to this alleged incident. One of the most brilliant things about Broomfield's film is that you see many sides to this story. Often you'll only ever see one side. We see the insurgents, marines and other Iraqi families. We get a glimpse every so often of how each section is coping and what they are going to do about it. This creates a lot of tension within thw scene and you gradually begin to feel for the Iraqis and understand he insugents better. By the end of the film you end up with a enormous hatred for the Americans. I won't say anything else as it will spoil the film. As I've just stated Battle of Heditha is incredibly Ant-American and Anti-War. It points out well that frustrations of the US marines serving in Iraq. We also are witnessed to one scne in particular, in which one of the insurgents declares he wishes he never planted the bomb that lead to this alleges massacre by the Americans. That shook me up. There are many many scenes which slightly changed my thoughts regarding the American soldiers, which i don't want to go into as it will spoil your viewing. Battle for Haditha is filmed very well indeed. Often by hand-held camera, which gives it that authetic feel. There are also so fine shots of Iraq and neighbouring Iraq backed up by some interesting diagetic music. Interestingly, it's hard to belive that there were very few professional actors used, most were real soliders at that time unbelievable. Battle for Haditha is one of the most powerful thoughtou-porviking films that I have seen. It brilliantly shows all sides of the argument and depicts what is alleged to have gone on well. I hope that this will get some sort of release in the states, but I understand that Broomfield is struggling to get distribution rights, which figures!! *Highly recomened watch* -
Chris M
The most powerful film made about the Iraq War to date. Sadly, its overrated.
Cast
-
Elliot Ruizas Cpl. Ramirez -
Falah Abraheem Flayehas Ahmad -
Yasmine Hananias Hiba
-
Andrew McClarenas Capt. Sampson -
Eric Mehalacopoulosas Sgt. Ross -
Duraid A. Ghaiebas Rashied
-
Oliver Bytrusas Jafar -
Aya Abbasas Safa -
Matthew R. Knollas Cpl. Matthews
-
Nathan De La Cruzas Cpl. Marcus -
Jayse Willetteas Pfc. Cuthbert -
Thomas Hennessey Jr.as Doc
-
Tony Spenceras Pfc. Roberts -
Vernon Gainesas Lcpl. Sosa -
Antonio Tostadoas Lcpl. Jimenez
-
Ali Adill Aj-Kaaas Iraqi Translator -
Siham Rashidas Asma -
Ibrahim Fuadas Abdullah
-
Majd Hijjawias Woman Shot in Street -
Juliet Koshabaas Saba -
Jeffery Nabilas Ahmad's Son
-
Rita Nabileas Ahmad's Daughter -
Murtada Namiras Foreign Fighter -
Fahed Borhanas Foreign Fighter
-
Adnan Ahmadas Foreign Fighter -
Shala'a Ghalias Foreign Fighter -
Huda Jasebas Foreign Fighter
-
Salem Ait Ali Belkacemas Foreign Fighter -
Rafic Ali Ahmadas Foreign Fighter -
Nabil Emmanuelas Foreign Fighter
-
Muna Jasebas Foreign Fighter -
Doa'a Jasebas Foreign Fighter -
Nick Shakooras Pfc. Hanoon
-
Danny Martinezas Lcpl. Santos -
Joe Chaconas Lcpl. Lopez -
Fuad Ismailas Walied
-
Ilham Talibas Ilham -
Yehyea Fuadas Abdul Rahman -
Adra'a Fuadas Abdulhamied Daughter
-
Hakim Fuadas Abdulhamied Son -
Hikmat Fuadas Abduhamied Daughter -
Hussain Fuadas Abduhamied Son
-
Raheem Majidas Uncle Jehad -
Abbas Ghanimas Mr. Yunis -
Iman Razzaas Um Mahmood
-
Hanneen Abbasas Huda -
Ibtisam Shamarieas Grandmother -
Hameed Sahyas Uncle Fleyih
-
Shukrieh Hameedas Fleyih's Wife -
Bahram Sahyas Fleyih's Son -
Munther Jabbaras Night Raid 1 Family Member
-
Sundus Muntheras Night Raid 1 Family Member -
Rafl Muntheras Night Raid 1 Family Member -
Revan Muntheras Night Raid 1 Family Member
-
Rania Muntheras Night Raid 1 Family Member -
Rosanna Muntheras Night Raid 1 Family Member -
Ali Majidas Night Raid 2 Family Member
-
Alhashmyas Night Raid 2 Family Member -
Suad Hatas Alias Night Raid 2 Family Member -
Noor Hussain Alias Night Raid 2 Family Member
-
Aram Alias Night Raid 2 Family Member -
Saidar Alias Night Raid 2 Family Member -
Zamily Laftaas Night Raid 3 Family member
-
Sabeeha Flefelas Night Raid 3 Family Member -
Mokhlis Zamilas Extra -
Soa'ad Mokhlisas Night Raid 3 Family Member
-
Mazen Zamilas Extra -
Helen Zamilas Night Raid 3 Family Member -
Maher Zamilas Extra
-
Marzan Mokhlisas Night Raid 3 Family Member -
Hamzeh Zedanas Person at Party -
Aseel Zedanas Person at Party
-
Laith Zedanas Person at Party -
Hanan Samias Extra -
Huthaifa Albnnaas Person at Party
-
Ayham Baha'aas College Boy -
Hussam Karimas College Boy -
Sam Yehyaas College Boy
-
Naseem Baha'aas College Boy -
Nazar Khalidas Singer -
Ali Odebatas Olive Tree Man
-
Yasser Yehyaas Taxi Driver -
Kibril Hambelas Major General Richard Kipper -
Wil Wrightas Marine Extra
-
Guss K.H. Abu Khurmahas Marine Extra -
Abdullah A.N. Irshaidas Marine Extra -
Hassan M. Al Amirias Marine Extra
-
Adnad Alakeras Marine Extra -
M.F. Abdallahas Marine Extra -
Omar M.S. Suleimanas Marine Extra
-
Yazeed H.M. Abdul Hakmehas Marine Extra -
Mohammed Abdul Qaderas Marine Extra -
Rafeq Asfouras Extra
-
Amma Theyabas Extra -
Ahmad Ala'aas Iraqi Soldier -
Sabah Abedas Iraqi Soldier
-
Daweh Ameras Extra -
Yousef Shamshoonas Extra -
Rafa'at Raedas Extra
-
Waed Salimas Extra -
Rami Rfias Extra -
Ali Thahbas Extra
-
Yousef Hasimas Extra -
Moyad Sa'adas Extra -
Yasin Hasimas Extra
-
Abdulsallam Oulwanas Extra -
Marie Alias Extra -
Raji Salihas Extra
-
Fatimah Saebas Extra -
Zamil Ouefas Extra -
Nadeer Alias Extra
-
Fatima Najmas Extra -
Muhnnad Salimas Extra -
Norhan Alias Extra
-
Oday Kathemas Extra -
Sandi Thaeras Extra -
Idair Khoshabaas Extra
-
Mayas Issaas Extra -
Safa'a Husseinas Extra -
Samir Al Khaldias Extra
-
Ahmad Alshamirias Extra -
Sabiha Abdullahas Extra -
Ala'a Tahseenas Extra
-
Esra Alias Extra -
Wijdan Tahaas Extra -
Adeeb Jameelas Extra
-
Deyana Adillas Extra -
Sam Hameedas Extra -
Dhia'a Khalilas Extra
-
Zuher Alessaas Extra -
Abdullah Yaseras Extra -
Jabbar Salehas Extra
-
Ghassan Amjadas Extra -
Azez Ouriebas Extra -
Raj'a Jabbaras Extra
-
Falah Mahdias Extra -
Salamih Oudihas Extra -
Ali Kathimas Extra
-
Adel Odebatas Jafar's Uncle -
Nabeel Koniyas Sheikh -
Saqar Soudias Iraqi Soldier
-
Salah Abd Al Amiras Iraqi Soldier -
Tayebeh Amjadas Extra -
Majid Hameedas Extra
-
Forat Redaas Extra -
Majd Kareemas Extra -
Salah Fozias Extra
-
Ban Amjadas Extra -
Aws Asaadas Extra -
Sezar A. Mahammedas Extra
-
Samir Salahas Extra -
Mana Mohammedas Extra -
Ghazwan Nayemas Extra
-
Ali Giesas Extra -
Manar Abdallateefas Extra -
Hellen Zamilas Extra
-
Wesal Kamilas Extra -
Laith Sobneas Extra -
Madeeha Hassanas Extra
Now you can share movies with your friends on Facebook!
- Discover movies your friends are watching
- Keep track of what you want to see
- Add your reviews to your Timeline