Breaking the Waves Reviews and Ratings



  • November 28, 2009
    Lars von Trier and his taste for inconsistent cameras drives me bonkers. It's this holier-than-thou filming style, where he thinks he's pure by using traditional methods and saving cinema, that gives any of his films meagerness. He's as delusional as Emily Watson's character.
  • November 3, 2009
    If you think this movie is good, you can check "Dancer in the Dark". I, myself couldn't understand why this director makes this kind of movies.
  • October 28, 2009
    An elegy of a passionate,disproportionate nonetheless relationship,it's not that a divine creature could have controlled the subsequent actions of Bess,Von Trier IS the maestro who doesn't takes sides for all that matters.he preferably speaks through an alarm clock,the one which ...( read more)vitalizes our inner strength and where religion is (arguably) the "foreigner".
  • October 24, 2009
    WEB-LETTERBOX. Magnífica y depurada alegoría que tiene la fortuna de contar con un reparto de primera. No solo Emily Watson se destaca, sino también Stellan Skarsgaard y, más aún, Katrin Cartlidge. Es asombrosamente precisa en su exploración de la dimensión espiritual de una pers...( read more)ona psicológicamente inadaptada. / Magnificent and pure allegory that has the fortune of boasting a great cast. Not just Emily Watson stands out, but also Stellan Skarsgaard and, even more, Katrin Cartlidge. It is amazingly precise in exploring the spiritual dimension of a psychologically maladjusted person.
  • October 23, 2009
    Deeply tragic and still boring. I come to think I simply don't like Lars von Triers movies with these unbearable minimalistic conversations.
  • October 14, 2009
    It is not my favourite Lars von Trier, I much prefer his America trilogy over his Golden heart trilogy (of which this movie is the third), because of the former being more conceptual and I think that fits more nicely (as in being contradictive) into von Trier's radical views.

    E...( read more)mily Watson is mesmerizingly brilliant in this movie, and I think she should have gotten more praise for her performance, not even in the form of an Academy Award (which went to Frances McDormand) but in general. She is a very underappreciated actress. The rest of the cast was solid and not as illustrious as in other von Trier movies (such as Dogville or Manderlay). Cinematography was top notch but the basic premise of the movie (while not its execution) is the apogee of the movie. Both very human and inhuman at the same time, the movie depicts a dance to a song of life that is both tragic and full of love, and while it is utterly bizarre and perverted we should all be able to relate to it, as the most basic human emotions bring the most extreme with them usually. The ending of the movie pushed the film into a high quality tier for me, but I do not want to spoil it. It is highly watchable and my rating predominantly relates to the other von Trier films and is highly relative.
  • October 11, 2009
    Excellent. One of the most important works of Lars von Trier.
  • October 10, 2009
    Another devastator. Lars up to one of his earlier films tackling the concept of Love and Religion. Sexually awkward at times this still really got me into some of the issues. The plot is really interesting. Well acted... perhaps as all Lars a bit too long. The only real dissapoin...( read more)tment is a lack of a stronger ending. But still worth seeing.
  • October 10, 2009
    Having decided to look through the works of Lars von Trier I?ve seen most of his movies as having some good ideas behind them, but ultimately finding most of them to not really work as a whole. The same is true to some extent of this film, but it ultimately holds up a lot better...( read more) than the other films I?ve seen. What is interesting about the movie is that the main character?s plight is ultimately not the responsibility of an oppressive and uncaring society, its ultimately the result of faith and love leading someone toward self destructive ends. Thus this is an attack on two things that society has lauded unquestioningly. That is interesting and provocative, and the film?s visual style is pretty effective. My problem with the film is that its main character is an emotional infant who at times seems to be borderline retarded. It doesn?t ring true to me and this is the same major problem I had with Dancer in the Dark. What sets Waves apart from Dancer is that Emily Watson handles the role a lot better than Björk did and the story also felt a lot less contrived. As such this is probably the most consistent Von Trier film I?ve seen, but it still isn?t really a work I can really call great.
  • September 25, 2009
    Von trier hit the spot again !loves Emily Watson,loves Stellan Skarsgaard,loves the soundtrack,and loves the powerful and dogmatic ending !
  • September 14, 2009
    Utterly depressing, Heartbreaking, Soul Crushing. These are all things that can accurately be said about this film. But despite that this film is well made and beautifully directed.
  • September 13, 2009
    I wish I could find the words to review this film and talk about it for days. But there are just some movies that no matter what you say about them, it just isn't enough. Brilliantly stunning performances (I'd bow to Emily Watson if I saw her), in what is all together for me Lars...( read more) Von Trier's best film. A heart-breaking story about the power of love. Explosive and able to bring you to your knees. Simply grand cinema.
  • September 7, 2009
    Simply one of the most heartpounding pictures I have ever come across.
  • September 5, 2009
    Breaking the Waves is a 1996 film directed by Lars von Trier (It is the first film in Trier's 'Golden Heart Trilogy' which also includes The Idiots from 1998 and Dancer in the Dark from 2000) and starring Emily Watson. Set in the Scottish Highlands in the early 1970s and tells th...( read more)e story of Bess McNeill, who marries oil rig worker Jan, despite the apprehensions of her community and Calvinist church. Bess is somewhat simple and childlike, and has difficulty living without Jan when he is away on the oil platform. She prays for his return, and when he returns paralyzed after an industrial accident, she believes it is her fault.

    Breaking the Waves" is meticulous in its details, yet when the movie is over, there are tens of questions left unanswered.
    The performances are, in fact, uniformly excellent and that having been said, the real crux of Breaking the Waves is a circumstance that can't be revealed in a movie review. I just say that once the narrative concludes, von Trier gives us an "epilogue" that confounds all expectations. The last moments of this film are by far the most challenging. Without resort to mere words, von Trier breaks the bounds of narrative and presents a resolution that's as troublesome as it is fulfilling. In a bold refutation of its own grim, nearly sardonic logic, Breaking the Waves cuts to the quick of religious faith, personal sacrifice, and human existence.
    It's definitely the most poignant, heart-ripping movie I've seen so far.
  • September 2, 2009
    Probably the most underrated, overlooked and misunderstood film of all time. Don't let the awful American poster put you off either, because this is without a doubt the most beautiful film made in the last 25 years. Its subject matter, pace and Dogma style puts many people off, a...( read more)nd to be fair it not everybodies cup of tea, but give it a chance. The last scene, in my opinion, is the best ever in the history of Cinema, a bold statement I know by I stand by it! Brilliant!
  • August 30, 2009
    Emotionally, the film is devastating, and it is certainly not a cheery movie. The performances are rich and deep, Emily Watson is amazing. I was a bit disappointed in the ending however, but it is a very well crafted film.
  • August 26, 2009
    Hard movie to enjoy.
  • July 28, 2009
    Add a review (optional)...
  • July 15, 2009
    i would rate it as OK! no one can be so stupid or amuture like Bess (Emily Watson) in the movie. not practical at all.

    movie is soooo damn slow and dragged at every single scene.. it could have been an hour and 30 minutes movie easily. i literally got tired at some points and...( read more) watched my clock ticking over hours. but if i consider the acting part of the movie, Emily Watson did a remarkable job. she performed so brilliently and beautifully. its hard to believe that she would be different in her real life.
    loved her innocence..

    all stars in my rating goes to her acting.
  • July 3, 2009
    Perfect Valentine's Day viewing...

    If your Valentine's Days are filled with bitterness, recrimination and unflinching misogyny. Which most are, from what I can tell.
  • June 10, 2009
    Did NOT like this movie.
  • May 2, 2009
    Great acting and great storyline but this movie was so depressing that i did not enjoy it at all,i never want to watch it again.

    This movie left me feeling angry. Besides from Jan,his friends and the doctor i can honestly say i hated every other man in this movie,really reall...( read more)y hated them even the horrible little male children who threw the stones,little bastards. The women were not much better,infact the only character i really liked was Dodo,even Bess did my head in but the way she was treated by the islanders including her own family and men on the boat was vile and sickening.

    This could possibly be the most depressing movie i have ever seen.
  • April 28, 2009
    i have to see this one.,
    both tykwer and scorsese love this film
  • April 19, 2009
    As I watched this film, I wasn't quite sure what period this was set in, where it was, or what exactly was wrong with Bess. Was she nuts? Was she just a bit slow? Was she simply depressed by the religious passion of her town and family?I s this all for a man? Common..
    I watched...( read more) the whole thing with a skeptical eye. Von Trier's style of filming ( hand-held cameras) makes it look like a film from the early 70's) and it irritated me on some level, but then I loved the "chapter breaks" with the striking view of landscape and accompanied by pop music (from the 70's). Great music of Elton John Led Zeppellin etc..

    Nice movie, though, still I have my own opinion about this all,
  • April 12, 2009
    Not a bad movie but just disturbing.
  • March 5, 2009
    Deserves 6 stars really.
  • February 1, 2009
    Original, highly challenging story about love and faith featuring remarkable performances from Emily Watson and Stellan Skarsgård. Director Lars Von Trier brings his unique visual style to this tale of moral and spiritual complexity, and the singular power of love.
  • January 24, 2009
    first film of von Trier's 'Golden Heart Trilogy', and it is touching alright. it was absolutely astonishing. the final scene was kinda corny, but it fit like a glove in the story. and Emily Watson did one of the most beautiful performances i've seen.
  • January 17, 2009
    love this film. it mixes sex with puritanism!!!
  • January 12, 2009
    Another mesmerising piece of cinema from Lars Von Trier, so emotional, fascinating and sad.
  • January 7, 2009
    Although the cover of the dvd looks like something Richard Gere may star in, make no mistake...Lars von Trier has made a great film with stunning performances and dramatic intensity. In addition to its' message about sacrificial love, Breaking the Waves reveals the contrast betwe...( read more)en the repression of some types of religion and the individual spirituality.

    A simple summary doesn't really give you a feel for it. You have to feel the motivations through the Watson character, and you have to feel with her that she is always trying to do the right thing, out of love. She somehow pulls that off and allows you to understand her completely, becoming vulnerable in every way.

    Holy shit, this is a heavy film.
    Photobucket
  • January 3, 2009
    STELLAR. A must see.
  • November 23, 2008
    after i saw this film, a friend of mine said she wanted to see it. i warned her to go with another female friend so that they could discuss what she was going to see. she didn't heed my warning and now another therapist is one patient richer.
  • October 18, 2008
    Watson and Skarsgard are great. The "chapter" headings are really beautiful highlighting the countryside. The story is sad, touching and intense.
  • October 7, 2008
    Lars Von Trier takes us on an emotional tour-de-force, questioning love, commitment and religion. Emily Watson gives a great and memorable performance as the troubled Bess, and Katrin Cartlidge provides excellent support.
    The only flaw has to be that final scene!
  • October 4, 2008
    I don't really feel like giving this film much credit, but for all its hatefulness and misogyny and its impossibly warped view of the world, it does have a few strengths. Emily Watson's performance is one of them; it's nice to think that her Oscar nomination is appropriate reward...( read more) for the dignity she sacrificed here, weeping hysterically in every other scene and having eerie channeled dialogues with God in others. It is to her tremendous credit that she pulls them off, but again, this role is absolutely degrading. Bess is merely a conduit for Lars von Trier's inflamed "torturing good-hearted women" fetish. There's nothing to show for this movie except for the systematic destruction of a naive, slightly unbalanced woman and everything she loves.

    For a movie to have depth, it must first say something, and Breaking the Waves simply doesn't. The most you could probably ascribe to it is as a dialectic on Christianity, but the movie spins so far off its axis that it's completely ineffective for this purpose. If religion is futile, how do you explain Bess' sacrifice and the resulting consequence? The final few seconds of the movie? You can take it a step further and hone it into a faith vs. organized religion argument, but Bess is unironically colored as insane for the faith she exhibits. The movie is just looking for excuses to kick her while she's down and trying to make it seem purposeful.

    On an ideological basis, I'd have given this movie only one star. It is well-made and reasonably gripping on a narrative level, but only in the way that you can't turn away from a train wreck. Emily Watson's performance earns it another. If this movie doesn't imprint her name on the mind of any cinephile, nothing will. Past that, Breaking the Waves' value ends.

    Perhaps the greatest irony of all in the film is that the license plate on Bess' moped says "LOL."
  • September 27, 2008
    wow i have just seen this movie 4 the 1st time n think that this is a powerful movie 2 watch....this has got a good cast of actors/actressess throughout this movie...i think that emily watson is great throughout this movie...i think that the director of this Drama, Art House & In...( read more)ternational movie had done a really good job of directing this movie because you never know what 2 expect throughout this movie...its a sad movie 2 watch but its really good n enjoyable throughout....the scenery throughout this movie is really awsome...i think that Stellan Skarsgård (who plays the husband) plays the part of this chracters really well throughout this movie..this is a good movie n its really moving n powerful as well
  • September 3, 2008
    Pretty, inmensely talented Emily Watson gives an amazing performance, but her character is so extremly naive and stupid it becomes annoying, hard to care for her and I kept wanting to bash her skull. Still a great performance, though.
  • September 2, 2008
    Poignant, Intense & Thought provoking

    Lars Von Trier first sensitizes the viewers by the innocence & playful curiosity of Bess, once it sets in he unleashes unrestrained waves of suffering & grief. It is a heart wrenching story of a girl (Bess) living in a repressed and religiou...( read more)s community. Her husband whom she deeply loves is injured and asks her to make a sacrifice.

    This movie raises pertinent issues regarding love, religion, faith and sacrifice. It is a long movie and some people may be unnerved by the plot but it is difficult to brush aside the brilliant direction by Lars Von Trier and riveting performance by Emily Watson.

    'In the depth of winter, I finally learned that there was within me an invincible summer' these words by Albert Camus kept ringing in my mind as I watched this movie.
  • August 22, 2008
    Powerful. Hits close to home.
  • July 31, 2008
    Another slit-your-wrists classic from Lars von Trier. Definitely a precursor in mood and atmosphere to his musical outing, 'Dancer in the Dark.' Definitely worthwhile if you can deal with one downer of a film.
  • July 20, 2008
    what a great film!!!splendid acting!a film full of meanings!
  • July 18, 2008
    A truly unique viewing experience: I don't know many films that make you feel the way this one does. The entire thing kept leaving me in awe.
  • July 9, 2008
    Hermosa película de amor. Para corazones que ven más allá de lo aparente... ¿Tienes cosquillas en el corazón?
  • July 8, 2008
    Quite Sad And Moving.
  • July 7, 2008
    Great Story. Good to watch before "Dancer in the Dark" as it is somehow part of a trilogy along with "Idiotern". Last Scene affects my rating by either a half step up or down. I'll let you guess which one.
  • July 6, 2008
    Another degrading piece of shit from L Von Trier. But Emily Watson is amazing as usual.

Summary


Breaking the Waves Summary