Carmel

Carmel (2010)

  • 40% of critics liked it
    (5 reviews)

  • 0% of users liked it
    (21 ratings)

Israeli filmmaker Amos Gitai offers an impressionistic look at his nation's long history of armed conflict in this experimental feature. Carmel begins with a re-creation of a battle from the first century, with Hebrews fighting off an invading Roman army, and the cascade of images that follows… More

Unrated, 1 hr. 33 min.
Directed By
Amos Gitai
Written By
Amos Gitai
Genres
Documentary, Drama, Art House & International, Special Interest
In Theaters
Sep 13, 2009 Wide
NY MOMA

Critic Reviews

  • V.A. Musetto, New York Post

    Carmel will be embraced by Gitai fans, who are familiar with his work and ideas. Casual moviegoers will be perplexed.

  • Stephen Holden, New York Times

    An impressionistic family chronicle with a tender heart.

  • Michelle Orange, Village Voice

    Unfortunately, the viewer is left out of the equation.

  • Mark Keizer, Boxoffice Magazine

    In an era of impersonal filmmaking, Carmel is as personal as a movie can be without naked body parts.

  • David Fear, Time Out New York

    Gitai has never been shy about adding autobiographical elements to his dramas, which only underlines Carmel's central irony: His most blatantly personalized movie feels like his least personal statement to date.

Critic ratings and reviews powered by RottenTomatoes.com

Fresh (60% or more critics rated the movie positively)

Rotten (59% or fewer critics rated the movie positively)

Featured Audience Ratings

  • Greg S


    This confusing collection of sometimes surreal vignettes appears to be an autobiographical reflection by its Israeli director, mixed with recreations of a battle between Romans and Jews and poetry read by Jean Moreau. There are a few interesting moments, like when an Israeli and a… More

Photos

facebook_logo

Now you can share movies with your friends on Facebook!

  • Discover movies your friends are watching
  • Keep track of what you want to see
  • Add your reviews to your Timeline