Penelope Cruz, Ben Kingsley, Patricia Clarkson

Respected cultural critic and author David Kepesh (Ben Kingsley) is a middle-aged college professor who, for years, has lived in a state of "emancipated manhood." His romantic conquests are many; his ...( read more  read more... )lasting commitments, few. But when a stunning young student named Consuela Castillo (Penelope Cruz) enters his life, her otherworldly beauty captivates him to the point of obsession. Soon, their erotic relationship evolves into an undying and passionate love in this gripping drama that explores the power of love to blind, reveal and transform.

Flixster Users

60% liked it

67,828 ratings

Critics

74% liked it

112 critics

R, 1 hr. 48 min.

Directed by: Isabel Coixet

Release Date: February 10, 2008

Invite friends to see

DVD Release Date: March 17, 2009

Get It:

Stats: 1,756 reviews

Get movie widget Recommend it Add to Favorites

Your Rating



clear rating

Flixster Reviews (1,756)


  • October 6, 2009
    It certainly had to be difficult to adapt "The Dying Animal" onto the screen. First-rate American writer Philip Roth usually writes from first-person perspective, in a manner of inner monologue and he doesn't leave much air while he does that. His writing is rich with description...( read more) of emotion and thought and, as we know, these are the two main things one can't show on screen since they have to come out from the events and interaction between the characters. Screenwriter Nicholas Meyer took his chances few years ago with "The Human Stain" and failed miserably, the result being a messy, unconvincing drama (with both Anthony Hopkins and Nicole Kidman miscasted). Now, adapting "The Dying Animal" by the title "Elegy", he seem to recognized some of his past mistakes, but his script is still far from perfection, which, when dealing with Roth's work, seems to be an obligation.

    "The Dying Animal" is a powerful 120 page novella. It's as frightening and disgusting as it is fascinating, truthful and, ultimately, sad. Really, a hard to put down one. The level of Roth's human understanding is remarkable. With full complexity he draws a inner life of an 62-year David Kepesh (in the film, mostly convincing sir Ben Kingsley) who, upon starting an affair with 24 year old student Consuela Castillo (fairly good Penelope Cruz) starts to contemplate issues such as aging, death, the power of the female beauty, the fear of being left alone, sexual desire and loneliness. It's understandable that with that amount of themes, one have to make choices. The picture then focuses much on fear of being left alone and aging. The matter of sex isn't one bit as nasty and nearly as graphic, in fact is mostly stiffy, which makes the character of Kepesh lack certain level of emotional desperation, I believe, crucial, in Roth's book.

    There's a brilliant thread in the book-- secondary yet important for deeper understading of Kepesh, about relation with his son, Kenny, in the film played by Peter Sarsgaard. Sarsgaard, a fine actor, does what he can as an angry, frustrated son to make a relation with his father look convincing, but the structure of the script won't allow him since he shows up out of nowhere in the middle of the picture and whole meeting, full of resentment and anger lacks nessessary energy, turning out to be a wasted oppurtunity.

    Isabel Coixet impressed me with her "The Secret Life of Words" and she certainly was as a good choice to direct the story since she's good at building the whole picture upon two characters. She effectively plays with shadows, drawing the intimate, almost dark atmosphere of a relationship, uses wide, static shots and edit them minimalisticly, focusing our full attention on the interaction of the two.

    "Elegy" may be one of those films that makes you turn your attention to the book, but there are great moments here. Dennis Hopper is wonderful as Kepesh's friend and every scene with him is fantastic. Same goes for every minute of Patricia Clarkson's time on screen. It's an elegant, intelligent drama and, thankfully, it doesn't take itself too seriously.

    But I'd strongly recommend you to read the book first.
  • April 8, 2009
    Fascinating study of love, lust, aging and death - no really. Kingsley plays an initially unlikeably aloof poet professor whose brash exterior and ordered existence is disrupted by the beautiful young Cruz. This relationship forms the core of the film but an impressive supporting...( read more) cast flesh out Kingsley's other relationships. A thought provoking moving script is the icing on the cake.
  • April 5, 2009
    Please do NOT waste your time on this slow moving, painful to watch "Lifetime" movie that wastes the talent of Ben Kingsley. Even Penelope Cruz's hotness couldn't save this film! Skip the DVD.
  • April 2, 2009
    Respected cultural critic and author David Kepesh (Ben Kingsley) is a middle-aged college professor who, for years, has lived in a state of "emancipated manhood." His romantic conquests are many; his lasting commitments, few. But when a stunning young student named Consuela Casti...( read more)llo (Penelope Cruz) enters his life, her otherworldly beauty captivates him to the point of obsession. Soon, their erotic relationship evolves into an undying and passionate love in this gripping drama that explores the power of love to blind, reveal and transform. Elegy is a story about a certain type of man at a certain point in his life. A man who was married, but felt it was prison, ran away, and promised himself never to do it again. He has led a hedonistic lifestyle ever since. Now the man has reached an age where he realizes that his time on earth is reaching its end. However, he still chases women much younger than he is, so they can have no strings attached sex. This is no mid-life crisis, nor is he trying to escape reality. Even when her angles and cutting begin to feel like too much dithering, Coixet never loses her sense of humor, succinctly acknowledging during in a great scene.
  • March 25, 2009
    Another "getting old sucks" movie, but one that as usual, has some redeming ending where they all learn something. Not a bad film at all, especially if you're into Penelope Cruz. Ben Kingsley is a stud.
  • November 18, 2009
    about me and my love
  • November 5, 2009
    I don't even know where to start.
    First, they try to pass a 40 year old Penelope as a 20-something by putting a bow in her hair? Right.
    Penelope's character was supposed to be a cuban girl who moved to States when she was 11, but still cant speak clear English after all those ye...( read more)ars? WTF? Oh, right, they casted a retarded actress who can't fake the accent. Honestly, it's physically painful to listen to her speak english.
    And don't even get me started on how bad this grandpa must have smelled... You know that acid-y smell old people have? Disgusting!
    The characters are so plain that I couldn't have cared less for any of them, and the movie itself was too boring to involve me at any point, I just waited for it to finish. There were some deep thoughts and point's of view, but it was not worth watching just for the sake of them, as we are aware of those anyway.
  • October 27, 2009
    Elenco estranho, mas eu gostei. Isabel Coixet é ótima.
  • October 18, 2009
    Oh my gosh! I loved this movie so much!!! It had everything...love & lust, commitment & infidelity, pleasure & pain, youth & wisdom, friendships & relationships. Even life & death. This movie was deeply interesting and beautiful. I highly recommend it. Much better than many...( read more) films I've seen lately. Vicky Christina Barcelona...does't hold a candle to this one!

    He was so caught up in her beauty, he never understood how much she really loved him. He never took the time to appreciate WHO she was on the inside. I've known many men who could learn a lesson about looking inside...

    LOVED THIS MOVIE!!!
  • September 29, 2009
    29/09/09
    "The Biggest Surprise in a Man's Life Is Old Age ."
    This is GREAT.

Critic Reviews


October 1, 2008
Pete Hammond, Hollywood.com

Finally, a film for grown ups. full review

August 22, 2008
Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times

It's nicely done. full review

August 8, 2008
Kurt Loder, MTV

Ben Kingsley and Penelope Cruz, never better. full review

August 8, 2008
Claudia Puig, USA Today

A spare, meditative and melancholy film. full review

August 8, 2008
Nigel Andrews, The Financial Times

Elegy makes us question again the cinema's ability, without loss of heat and light, to translate Roth's subtle, high-voltage prose from page to screen. full review

August 4, 2008
David Edelstein, New York Magazine

Elegy is a spare, melancholy film that is so far in spirit from its source, Philip Roth's The Dying Animal, that I'm tempted to say we should abandon altogether the idea of adapting Roth. full review

View more Elegy reviews at RottenTomatoes.com

Comments


  • chrismid259
    July 16, 2008
    I actually wouldn't mind seeing this. Looks like an interesting movie.

Critic ratings and reviews powered by RottenTomatoes.com

Fresh (60% or more critics rated the movie positively)

Rotten (59% or fewer critics rated the movie positively)

Official Trailer

More Like This


Click a thumb to vote on that suggestion, or add your own suggestions.

  • Autumn in New York
    Autumn in New York (100%)
  • The Human Stain
    The Human Stain (50%)

Facts


No facts approved yet. Be the first

Elegy : Watch Free on TV


Movie Quizzes


No quizzes for Elegy. Want to create one?

Most Popular Skin


No skins yet. Interested in creating one?