Andrea Di Stefano, Asia Argento, Coralina Cataldi-Tassoni

Leaden horror costumer that takes its tenuous starting point from the classic Gaston Leroux novel of the same name. The twist in this variation is that the Phantom was raised by telepathic rats in the...( read more  read more... ) subterranean caverns beneath the opera house. Thus our feral Phantom (Julian "Ratboy" Sands) develops an obsessive love for up-and-coming diva Christine (Asia Argento), and sets about to seduce her to his dark, rodent existence. Although beautifully photographed, with lots of ornate period detail to catch the eye, this is largely a by-the-numbers supernatural horror story with scant gory set pieces as diversions. Fans of Dario Argento will yell "Rats!" and all else will merely shrug. And why are the rats telepathic, anyway? Screenwriting credits go to Gerard Brach, best known for his many collaborations with Roman Polanski, most notably Repulsion. However, none of his absurd sense of humor comes through in this film, which really needs it. A shame all around. The DVD includes a short interview with the film's star, Julian Sands, as well as a photo gallery, some dispensable making-of clips, spliced together to appear as a featurette (mostly in untranslated Italian) and a very informative article from Fangoria Magazine. --Jim Gay

Flixster Users

27% liked it

5,613 ratings

R, 100 min.

Directed by: Dario Argento

Release Date: November 20, 1998

Invite friends to see

DVD Release Date: November 30, 1999

Stats: 194 reviews

Get movie widget Recommend it Add to Favorites

Photos


None yet... Got one?

Your Rating



clear rating
Share on: Facebook Twitter

Flixster Reviews (194)


  • July 21, 2008
    This is . . . bad. The atmosphere is great and the gore is pretty satisfying, but . . . what is up with the rats, Dario? And where exactly is the Phantom's trademark mask - you know, the one on the front of the box? In case you haven't guessed, this definitely is not a stellar...( read more) example of a Phantom movie, or a giallo.
  • August 13, 2007
    A cool, weird and gorey version of Phantom of the Opera by Dario Argento, the mystery horror maestro from Italy. Contrary to the DVD cover, the Phantom doesn't wear a mask, and is played by the long-haired awesome actor Julian Sands. Dario's daughter Asia Argento plays the Phant...( read more)om's love Christine. The opera music is brief, and you can tell that Asia is lip-synching to it. The deaths are imaginative and gorey; I wished the bodycount was slightly higher. I like the cool trailer using The Smith's "How Soon Is Now" - too bad they didn't use that tune in the actual movie.
  • September 13, 2006
    Asia is good but what happened here? Nothing seems to quite come together.
  • July 1, 2009
    Gorgeous sets, costumes and photography, great Gothic atmosphere, but ouch, what a crude script by Gerard Brach and director Argento (whose fan I´m not, BTW) : especially rat-like, obnoxious "Phantom" and his treatment of fat Carlotta pollutes the fim . And Asia Argento does no...( read more)t even pretend to sing!
  • April 14, 2009
    horror.....triller....leh..mati weh tgk cite nie
  • February 7, 2009
    I've read some terrible reviews of this, but on watching it I was pleasantly surprised. It has rather high production values, but it is certainly melodramatic and rather nonsensical. If you can stomach that, it has something for almost everyone; fans of gory death scenes, fans of...( read more) nudity (particularly fans of Asia Argento's breasts), fans of unintentional comedy screaming, BBW fans, fans of poets having an argument in a pool, rat fetishists...
    Everyone except Leroux purists, who are not going to be happy with all the liberties taken with the original story - the phantom isn't even physically deformed.

    Verdict: Julian Sands with long hair, butt naked = yum. Two large, beautiful women = yum (even if one of them does get called a fat cow twice...). Two poets having a fight = hilarious. Fans of classic horror stay away. One for my collection.
  • January 25, 2009
    this is bad
    S U E THEM ALL!!!!

    ITS ONE OF THE WORST FILMS I EVER SAW
  • December 2, 2008
    Hmm... def a diff take on the classic, kind of a cross between PHANTOM & WILLARD '71 lol. Kinda awful. See it to say u have.
  • October 28, 2008
    I don't know, the thing is, Argento got balls to change the whole concept and not just add some awesome rats with a soul but a phantom more man than phantom, more flesh than mask and more likely for rat bestiality than anything else. I found the unconventional nature rather bizar...( read more)re, especially those having to do with Argento's daughter, like the one where she appears as some marooned mermaid or pirate or something. Also, this film, which I like, owes a lot of its effects to the older days, very odd and clearly looking fake as compared to what was being made with CG at that period. I don't know, this film never actually scares, but it was fun understanding Asia's character. Also, I must emphasize this, the scene with the Swiss chocolate paedophile is badass, every part of that edit is fabulous, even the massive throwing in the air of candy. Sweet.
  • October 17, 2008
    No thankyou - Not interested

Critic Reviews


No recent reviews.

Comments


  • xXxHarleyxQuinnxXx
    June 14, 2007
    WTF telepathic rats HAHA now i know im not watchen it or maybe i will just to see how funny it is!

Critic ratings and reviews powered by RottenTomatoes.com

Fresh (60% or more critics rated the movie positively)

Rotten (59% or fewer critics rated the movie positively)

More Like This


Click a thumb to vote on that suggestion, or add your own suggestions.

  • Lo Squartatore di New York (The New York Ripper)
    Lo Squartatore di New York (The New York Ripp... (0%)
  • Silent Hill
    Silent Hill (100%)
  • Final Destination 3
    Final Destination 3 (0%)
  • Dellamorte Dellamore (Cemetery Man) (Demons '95) (Of Death, of Love)
    Dellamorte Dellamore (Cemetery Man) (Demons '... (0%)

Facts


No facts approved yet. Be the first

Il Fantasma dell'... : Watch Free on TV


Il Fantasma dell'Opera (The Phantom of the Opera) Trivia

Movie Quizzes


No quizzes for Il Fantasma dell'Opera (The Phantom of the Opera). Want to create one?

Recent News


No recent headlines. Got one?

Most Popular Skin


No skins yet. Interested in creating one?