9.0/10
It takes a gifted filmmaker to truly respect the visual medium that is film. They say that most filmmakers just don't have a grasp on this concept; and for the most part, I agree. But I also agree that there are artists who understand that a film needs to… More
9.0/10
It takes a gifted filmmaker to truly respect the visual medium that is film. They say that most filmmakers just don't have a grasp on this concept; and for the most part, I agree. But I also agree that there are artists who understand that a film needs to look good to be entertaining; and these are the people who make highly respectable works of art. Andrei Tarkovsky started his career the right way with his debut feature "Ivan's Childhood"; a dark, poetic, and beautiful portrait of a youth who grew up during war-time. Some of my favorite films have similar attributes; brilliant visuals, and a timely story about children influenced by violence and war. "Ivan's Childhood", however, is one of the most brilliant films ever made, at least when it comes to films about rough childhoods. This is a film without comedy and without what most would call "joy". It's a cold, powerful, and nearly heartless film. But maybe that, as well as Tarkovsky's spot-on direction, is what makes it such a memorable and worthwhile experience. Whilst watching the film, I couldn't help but feel like this is one of the highest-budget film debuts I've ever seen. The picture (especially with its semi-recent Criterion Collection release, which restores the picture to its best quality) looks fantastic, and NOTHING about the film gives off a "low budget" feel. Its spectacular filmmaking, story-telling, and visualization. It's never a "war" movie (as some have described it), but more so a full-on drama; and a perfect one from the looks of it. I loved "Ivan's Childhood" because it is historic, inspiring, and influential. It makes us all kind of wish that we were born with the sort of visual genius that Tarkovsky was born with; but the reality is that wishing will not get us anywhere. You must be skillful to be a painter, and the same goes for a filmmaker. Tarkovsky is a natural-born filmmaker in the best sense of the phrase; a beautifully poetic man creating beautifully poetic films. His first film is brilliant; and I highly recommend that everyone see it. It's never over-long, which is surprising considering the story it tells, although it gets everything accomplished in its 95-minute run-time. It's a treasure; a gem. And that's what I love about it.
The film has a story; and it's a story of many layers. It is the tale of a young boy who was born and raised in war-time; World War II, to be precise. He lives in fear with a hint of ambition; longing to help serve his country. It's a sad film in the end; a tragic tale of loss and youth that shall not be forgotten after you've experienced it. I have watched "Ivan's Childhood" twice now, and let me tell you; I finally feel like I've seen the film in all its beautiful entirety. The story is told slowly but delicately; savoring room for little details, symbolism, and beautifully haunting imagery. Tarkovsky seems to have a gift for each of these things, and that probably why I'm pondering looking into more of his work soon. "Ivan's Childhood" is a powerful dose of youthful story-telling; and it is engaging both emotionally and in its narrative style. But what seems to take center stage here is the style; and in that sense, this film is a masterpiece in that department. The most unforgettable aspect of the film is how Tarkovsky's imagery blends in so well with the suitably bleak and dark story-line. I find it masterful, and I find "Ivan's Childhood" to be a complicated but unforgettable tragedy of a film. Some may think it is a mess, but if it is one, then it's a beautiful mess. They say that you cannot have a good film without a good story and that is true. I will tell you up front that "Ivan's Childhood" does have a story, and it's a damn good one. But half of the story is told through what we can see rather than what we can hear. If you find that you and your five senses are closely in-tact, then "Ivan's Childhood" is most definitely for you. Just don't doze off, since there's too much to see here for you to be sleeping on the job. Tarkovsky is talented; and I adore talented artists. Thus, I liked "Ivan's Childhood".
I found that Nikolai Burlyayev was very hard to ignore as Ivan. There was a haunting, nigh demeaning quality about the actor that elevated both his character and his performance to pure greatness. As I have expressed, I loved this film. Everything about it was completely arresting in a bleakly visual sort of way. Burlyayev's performance only does so much as help this film be better than it already is; and there's something very, very special about his efforts. He's a part of what makes "Ivan's Childhood" so darned intoxicating.
"Ivan's Childhood" has no regrets when it comes to expressing filmic art in the most bizarre, dark, but beautiful ways. I've seen worse when it comes to graphic war depictions, but "Ivan's Childhood" simply does not linger on such a thing; not even for a moment. The story does not care about the details of the war, but more-so the impact that the events have on its character. Ivan was surrounded by daily violence and eternal fear. We are shown how this affected him to great extents; and this is definitely what makes the film as powerful of a knock-out as it truly is. The cinematography is absolutely breathtaking; I'm not going to lie about that. Tarkovsky nearly demands that this film be visually awesome; and some of the shots are just plain intimidating. But that's why they're so darned unforgettable. The film also has a relentless, consistent sense of dread going on throughout. The film makes use of its visual style as well as the score to create a perfect atmosphere, and quite frankly, it creates a perfect film as well. I've seen a lot of great films in my time, but "Ivan's Childhood" is great because it has shown me something that few other films truly have; pain, sadness, and power. Sure, we've all seen a little bit of each. But seldom do we see them together. Ah, hell; look at me. Only one film in to his career, and I'm already praising Tarkovsky as if I'd known his career for years. It sort of feels that way, now doesn't it? I adored this film for its artistic merit and its stunning visual mastery. It is a visual masterpiece. And that's enough to make it great.
I've been watching some seriously depressing films lately. That's not to say that "Ivan's Childhood" is a masterpiece as far as depressing films go, since it's not even THAT depressing of a movie (or at least not enough of one to turn away those who despise general on-screen depression), mostly since it's a masterpiece in many other things. But it's a gritty film; relentless in its emotional impact and powerful in its story-telling. There is no other film quite like it, and frankly, that kind of statement only applies to some of the best films out there. I love "Ivan's Childhood". I loved the story, I loved the visuals, and I loved Tarkovsky's wondrously ominous sense of direction. It's official; the guy is a genius. But then again, his work has proved to be influential, so he must be, right? Yes, right; he must be a great man. He must have been one, at the least. However, despite my personal love for this film, Tarkovsky didn't seem to share the same sort of admiration. He complained that the film was a disappointment, and that the script wasn't as he had wanted it to be. All I can say to that is; oh well. There are people who can appreciate it, and it's too bad that the director himself cannot. But I'm sure that Tarvosky learned to love his debut as time went on. But then again; so did most people. This film has aged very well. It's the kind of movie that will never age anything more or less than well; and that's saying a whole lot of good when regarding the thing. It's dark, seductive craft is not to be missed; and I feel that "Ivan's Childhood" should be seen by just about everyone; although it is not FOR everyone. None the less, it's a classic. I will now go on to watch other Tarkovsky masterpieces. Wish me luck there.