Hollywood has been dramatizing the lives of famous musicians almost from its very beginning. From the Al Jolson Story to the Benny Goodman Story to the Buddy Holly Story to Walk The Line, and no group has been represented more in film than the Beatles. Based on the memoirs of… More
Hollywood has been dramatizing the lives of famous musicians almost from its very beginning. From the Al Jolson Story to the Benny Goodman Story to the Buddy Holly Story to Walk The Line, and no group has been represented more in film than the Beatles. Based on the memoirs of Lennon's half-sister Julia, it's one of the more unromanticized and factual movies of its kind, covering his life from ages 14 to 17 (approximately), and focusing on his relationship with his estranged mother and the aunt who raised him (Beatle fans looking to see yet another re-telling of how the group got together may be disappointed, as there's little screen time devoted to the fab four). What shaped the adolescence of the man who would go onto found the biggest musical group of all time?
Aaron Johnson ("Kick Ass") plays the John Lennon character much the way every expert Beatles fan would expect: part wise-ass hoodlum, part sensitive artist, and most of the time both sides are colliding simultaneously in a way that conflicts and confuses the "nowhere boy". Bob Dylan once said after reading a wildly exaggerated article about himself in the newspaper, "I'm sure glad I'm not me". The teenaged Lennon doesn't seem to know who he is or what he wants, it's as if he's trapped in a performance, always trying to please his audience. Part of his acting out might've been seeking the attention of his aloof aunt Mimi, or maybe it was just A.D.D., the movie hints at both possibilities. When one day his free-spirited mother comes back into his life, it seems to correspond with his discovery of rock-n-roll music. It's here the die has been cast and his fate is finally sealed. After watching a newsreel, John asks his mother "Why couldn't God have made ME Elvis Presley?", to which his mother responds "Because he was saving you for John Lennon". Sure, it's a little bit cheesy (and the movie at times can't help itself), but it certainly doesn't seem outside the realm of possibility for her to have said it. The relationship between the two sometimes hints at oedipal, but it does so gently, so as not to offend the beatlemaniacs too much.
One thing Nowhere Boy does extremely well is show the humble origins of greatness. It's hard to believe, amongst all the ridiculous 50s pompadours (so accurately re-created) and smoking teens, that this barely-able-to-play band would go onto become the Beatles, but it most likely all had to start in some such fashion. It's hard to say whether youth creates culture or culture creates youth, but so many kids of the late 50s got their behavior and concept of "cool" from the movies (every kid is doing his best James Dean or Marlon Brando imitation). Nowhere Boy nails this youthful longing to have an identity, even if it's one the kids co-opted from hollywood back in the day. It reminds me of the days of 'gangsta rap' from the early 90s, where everyone was from the hood. Everyone wants to be a somebody.
It's hard to draw a distinction between "Nowhere Boy" the film and the actual life of John Lennon, and this is probably a good sign the film is a great biography. Rather than deify the Lennon legend, it tries to create the story of an actual flawed human being. While the music might not be given the recognition it deserves (Lennon seems to come to music as a means of meeting girls, something that seems highly dubious, given his dedication to it), it is in the end what gives it all meaning. Would John Lennon with a more idyllic childhood have gone onto create the Beatles, or would the world have simply gained another draftsman or dock worker? If ritalin had been around in the 1950s, would he have grown up to be just another good citizen, rather than some rock-n-roll scalliwag? Fate decrees things for some. A sheltered life doesn't necessarily mean a happy life, and a happy life doesn't necessarily lead to greatness. Lennon's early tumult lead to musical creations so wonderful, they still change lives 40-some years later.