Stranger Than Fiction Reviews and Ratings



  • November 25, 2009
    What if someone tells you that you are going to die? Is it something to be scared of, or is it something to be proud of; knowing that you are the hero in a bestseller about your own life?

    Spoiler:

    Meet Harold Crick (Will Ferrell). He is a real-life character in his own life. He...( read more) is most fond of numbers, counting everything countable. He is a total mathematics freak. He has this unusual obsessive-compulsive attitude about things. He is a vehement follower of his own set of routines making his life a little less than usual, in short tedious.

    Harold works for the American internal revenue. He collects and accounts taxes from business firms and reports to his office if anything is wrong, and so on. To push forward the comprehensibility of the nature of his occupation, people hate him and no further explanation why.

    Living his seemingly boring life, everyday is like yesterday, and tomorrow is expected to be the same as yesterday and today. A voice of a woman narrates Harold?s life as it goes on every day. Until one day, Harold hears the voice of the narrator from his background. It seems so vividly odd that the omniscient narrator likes to tell what he is currently doing and has a vocabulary like that of a professional writer. Harold, in his most normal mind decides to consult a psychiatrist. The first finding tells that he might be suffering from schizophrenic psychological disorder. But he is normal enough to suffer from that condition. Next thing he does is to consult a literature expert. Jules Hilbert (Dustin Hoffman) is a well known literature extraordinaire. He has studied his passion for years and Harold thinks he might be the one to help him solve his problem since the voice he hears is somewhat literary-educated or might have gone in writing professionally. Dr. Hilbert, in his most earnest appeal decides to help Harold. With his coffee-quenching antic, he dabbles into reviewing Harold?s case and asks the latter to report to him often about the progression in his case.

    It is one terrible day, an ordinary Wednesday when Harold hears the quite shocking news from the same voice that narrates his story. The voice said that he is going to die no sooner than soon.

    If Harold is a math freak, unfortunately, he is a jerk when it comes to girls. In a bakery where he collects taxes, he meets a girl named Ana Pascal (Maggie Gyllenhaal). This tattooed revolutionary-thinking girl is the owner of the said bakery. She is a Harvard drop-out with a belief that she could make the world happy with baking cookies. And for Harold, it is true; because he instantly falls in love with her. Later we know that Ms. Pascal is falling in love with Harold too.

    The other story:

    Karen Eiffel (Emma Thompson) is a famous writer of fictional books. What makes her different is that she only writes tragedies. She has a writer?s block and for ten years has not written books, until this one. She often endows herself in imagining how her character heroes would die in such interesting but enjoyable manners for the readers. What we don?t know is, she is the voice that Harold Crick hears every day, occasionally. No one character in this film knows that she has been writing Harold?s fate in an instant. Even Karen herself does not know that Harold is a real-world character. The twist begins when Harold sees Karen on television. He has recognized the same accented voice that tells his story every day. He has recognized the voice that talked about his death. So he went to see Karen and make inquiries about the strange happenings in his life.

    Harold and Karen meet and both are awed evidently. Karen did not expect her character would appear in front of her and be solid and tangible as Harold. Same thing, Harold did not expect to be meeting face to face with the voice he hears every day.

    It all becomes touchingly dramatic when Harold has read the latter parts of the novel about his own life. In the end, it says that he is going to die. But he commends the writer?s ability to write such beautiful story like the story of his life. He asks Karen to continue the novel and the rest is for you to find out.

    First, it is a story both fictional and real. It is fictional in a way that Harold?s life is only narrated or soon-to-be subject for a fictional novel. It is real because we see true human emotions, meaningful and colorful. When Harold learned to live by himself, that is the rising action of the film; which brings us later to the climax when Harold discovers that he has nowhere to go but to die soon. It is a film with so much effort to evoke the audience to live life in your fullest, fulfill your passion, love all you can, and be the best you can be. In the end, it is not a single line on a novel about your life will dictate the way you live it. But it is you who will be your own writer.

    The movie is somewhat existential in theme. There is a certain point in Harold?s life when he learns to play the guitar, he pursues the girl he admires, and he learns how to get rid of all his routines. It is a turning point in his life. He learns to be the best he can and be for someone (Ana) and for himself. We do not have to learn that we are about to die no sooner for us to discover the essence of our existence. That is why Harold just doesn?t mind the voice that he hears sometimes, because he knows that it is he who molds what he is to become.

    The film employs good photography. It is quite well-looking from the first shots up to the last. It also has interesting visual effects to help the audience envisage the given scenario at full details. The screenplay is certainly funny especially with thorough extraction of actors Will Ferrell, Emma Tohmpson, Dustin Hoffman, and Maggie Gyllenhaal. The film has an interesting plot that established the characters into more concrete identities throughout. At first, we can imply that there are two unrelated stories in this film, Harold?s and Karen?s. The director has created seemingly two different worlds, one implied fictional, and one real, but merged them down quite extraordinarily in the end. Lastly, the film is concluded by a story-relevant and upbeat song by Spoon.

    Upon watching this film, the film ?Oedipus Wrecks? tingled in my mind; it is Woody Allen?s featured film in the anthology ?New York Stories? together with fellow New Hollywood directors Martin Scorsese and Francis Ford Coppola. In ?Stranger than Fiction?, if Harold hears a voice, in ?Oedipus Wrecks?, Woody Allen?s character sees and hears his mother with enlarged scale ghostly image in the atmosphere of New York City. It is such a funny presentation. That collection is totally great especially Martin Scorsese?s ?Life Lessons?, but it also exhibits such a lousy presentation from the father-daughter team-up Francis and Sofia Coppola in their feature titled ?Life Without Zoe".
  • November 21, 2009
    Only Will Ferrell film I've liked so far.
  • November 12, 2009
    Will Ferrel at his finest. Clever, beautiful.
  • November 11, 2009
    The biggest highlight, of course, is Kaufman's talent. Since his name is already a strong promise, the expectations are inevitably high. The concept is incredibly smart, but just as I expected, the film started beautifully and Forster achieved to make it drag later on. Good film ...( read more)to watch, but even the couple chemistry was non-existent.

    68/100
  • November 3, 2009
    a ridiculous story...
  • November 1, 2009
    What could have been in interesting idea never managed to sell me that it was telling me an interesting story. I think it had to do with the lack of charm in the main character, a flaw that can't be entirely attributed to the actor, because at some stages he managed to pull off s...( read more)ome lines that I was suprised were able to be said non-cheesily. Also I somehow never bought the chemistry with the main characters.
    Dustin Hoffman and Emma Thompson get the most intriguing characters of the bunch and I wish they'd gotten much more screen time.
  • October 28, 2009
    unique story ^^
    but didn't have a special message to me >.<
  • October 25, 2009
    Great story! The actors did a magnificent job, and of course the directors too.
  • October 21, 2009
    Once I read the synopsis I immediately wondered how this movie could logically explain a story of a man is living within a fictional story that he is aware about. Although while watching this I was so engrossed in the film that it needed no answer whatsoever. That element is very...( read more) similar to the story of Groundhog Day.
    Will Farrell could not surprise me anymore than he did in this film, the man can act. Thet love story between Farrell and Gyllenhall's characters was done so well with great development and chemistry.
    The trailer is totally misleading, it paints a picture of a typical semi funny Will Farrell comedy when it is really a very dramatic film that takes you on an emotional roller coaster.
  • October 18, 2009
    The film is both literary and stylish, an odd mix, but one that works extremely well.

    This Guy Over Here picks this film as one of the best of the 2000s
  • October 17, 2009
    Not nearly as funny as you're led to believe, especially considering it stars Will Ferrell and the movie trailer leads you to think this is funny. Actually, is a very depressing story and a bit sadistic/voyeuristic. So if you're a freakstick you might enjoy it. I didn't.
  • October 17, 2009
    Will Ferrell can't act.
  • October 16, 2009
    this is just a great film. Good to see will farrell in a non-comedic role, plays it really well. The obscure storyline is excellent and without giving anything away it does work as there is not a magical background behind why harold crick can hear narration. First rate.
  • October 15, 2009
    boring. we had to watch it for english
  • October 14, 2009
    Extravaganza. Truly inspiring. Wittily directed & written. Will Ferrell's subtle, tune-down way off acting is extra prepossessing.
  • October 14, 2009
    Very interesting role for Will Farrell. Did a great job though.
  • October 14, 2009
    Unique premise for a comedy with a touch of unexpected drama. Who ever thought that being audited by the IRS would be this entertaining?
  • October 11, 2009
    Very funny and original movie about a man who hears a female voice narrating his every move. Will is very comical. It is also good to see Emma as the quirky narrator.
  • October 10, 2009
    How true is this Movie?!! Your mind will wonder what is real or what you would prefer to be!
  • October 4, 2009
    Fantastic, Will Ferrell pulls of a half-serious role with flair. Get more of this in!
  • October 1, 2009
    It was very good , the story is totally unpredictable , at first sight it seemed kinda boring , but it has an interesting ending , I really freaked when he was hit by the bus , but its good he didnt die , because then it would become tragedy and i dont like tragedy
  • October 1, 2009
    Interesting idea, greatly performed. Believable characters and good acting. Funny and touching.
  • September 30, 2009
    [2009.09.30 on DVD] Am I a tragedy or a comedy?
  • September 27, 2009
    Different than what I was expecting, but enjoyable.
  • September 26, 2009
    An interesting story, though a little too morbid for me.
  • September 26, 2009
    would of liked it better if he died.
  • September 24, 2009
    Well what can I say about this movie?? it has a good plot about it and the moments leading up to when he gets hit by the bus is interesting. When he gets hit we would all think that he would die but it took me by suprise when he ended up in hospital so all in all a very good movie!!
  • September 21, 2009
    When I saw that Will Ferrell works in the movie I said: " I'm going to laugh ". But, it's not what I thought, because, at the beginning, I laughed but then it turns into a drama.
  • September 19, 2009
    This is a wonderful, wonderful movie. Completely underrated.
  • September 18, 2009
    Stranger Than Fiction is a film that I love more & more every time I watch it. Everything that happens in the film is brilliant and incredibly layered by Marc Forster who is becoming one of the best directors of this generation in just four films. His skills, from his ability to ...( read more)get the most out of a scene to the handling of his actors, are exceptional. Thing is, like his other film, the thriller Stay, Stranger Than Fiction shows many layers, which may come as a surprise for those just looking for a solid comedy.


    It starts out simple enough. Will Ferrell stars as Harold Crick, an IRS auditor who leads a very boring life. Nothing ever interesting has happened to him in his life. It all changes when he finds that there is a voice following him, telling him (although not directly) about his life, his thoughts, and his actions. But when the voice says that he'll be facing his imminent death, he seeks out the help of a literary professor (Dustin Hoffman) to somehow stop his dour fate.

    Hold on, cause it doesn't stop there. The voice in question is Karen Eiffel (a superb Emma Thompson), an author with writers block who can't figure out how to kill the protagonist for her newest novel, Harold Crick. She is helped (reluctantly, of course) by a woman (Queen Latifah in her best role yet) sent by Karen's publishers to act as some sort of muse to help cure Eiffel of her writers block.

    As it is, the story-within-a-story plot by Zach Helm definitely brings to mind Charlie Kaufman's script for Adaptation. The difference is how director Marc Forster handles the material. Marc Forster crafts some fun moments throughout: the way Harold reacts to Eiffel's narrations are hilarious and the scene in the guitar shop is magnificent to say the least.

    Forster doesn't skimp in the drama department however, as he keeps a firm grip on reality despite the clearly out there premise. Credit Forster and screenwriter Zach Helm for creating believable and sympathetic characters and turn them human. Maggie Gyllenhaal is the perfect example of this, as the bakery owner Harold is auditing and ultimately falls for. She starts out disliking him (even telling him to "get bent") but her character gradually softens and its like magic.

    Still, the star here is Will Ferrell, who gives Harold a heart and soul as he comes to terms with the events that have taken place. Ferrell is at his absolute best here, from his reaction that his fate is already planned, shows a subtlety and emotion that feels genuine, making potential viewers scratch their heads as they wonder why he doesn't do this type of movie more often, since he is clearly able to hold his own against the talents of Gyllenhaal, Hoffman, and Thompson.

    That question may never be answered, but whats here is an amazing comedy drama by a director who is clearly on a roll. It's a well-written, excellently crafted, and superbly acted film that has all the potential to be an enduring classic.
  • September 16, 2009
    It was different, that's why it's good. Will Farrell was very good here, I usually don't like his movies, but this one I do like. Maggie Gyllenhaal, Dustin Hoffman, Emma Thompson and Queen Latifah were good as supporting roles. I don't think I'll watch it again soon, but someday,...( read more) sure :)
  • September 11, 2009
    Odlican film, iznenadio me kompletan sadrzaj, svida mi se cijela ideja oko toga. Preporucujem da ga pogledate!
  • September 11, 2009
    11/09/09
    "Truth is stranger than fiction."
    One of my favourite movies ever.
  • September 9, 2009
    very good.....slow start though
  • September 8, 2009
    When I first started this movie, I felt it was almost too odd for my tastes. However, as the film progressed, it truly surprised me, though. In fact, I ended up really liking it. Highly recommended! A must see!
  • September 6, 2009
    Awesome film. I absolutely loved it. Visually stunning and a well written story.
  • September 3, 2009
    This film didn't really make much sense to me, it did have its funny moments, just not enough to make it a great film. An odd choice for Marc Forster to direct and a misconceived idea by Zach Helm.
  • August 27, 2009
    I found it to be boring, Will Ferrell is one of my favorite actors but I just didn't find anything exceptional about this movie.
  • August 24, 2009
    Turns out that, given the right script and supporting cast, Will Ferrell is a perfectly serviceable actor. I have to give a ton of credit to the incredibly original screenplay, which is so unique that I'm shocked it ever came out of Hollywood.

    I hate to spend half my review tal...( read more)king about why this movie didn't rank even higher, but ... Ferrell's character and performance is a bit underwhelming. I don't think that's necessarily his fault, just the way he is written. (pun) Finally, I thought the ending was a bit of a letdown. How ironic.
  • August 22, 2009
    probably the best movie i have ever seen. it is a perfect balance between serous and funny. while a lot of movies try desperately to make a movie seem a lot like life. this i can relate to more then any others. and has one of the best endings for a movies. i truly love this movie
  • August 22, 2009
    creative story-telling of interconnected lives...
  • August 18, 2009
    konsep unik tersaji dalam film ini. banyak adegan-adegan yang mengharukan dan begitu manis, ditutup dengan ending yang sangat menarik. Ini salah satu film yang sangat indah. Tidak bisa dipercaya Will Ferrel yang melakukan ini.
  • August 17, 2009
    Muy original. Me gusto.
  • August 16, 2009
    an excellent film. the story is a brilliant one and so well told. the cast are just excellent throughtout the whole film. this film is to will ferrell as the truman show was to jim carrey. this film is soo worth a watch.
  • August 15, 2009
    A really interesting idea combined with some solid filmmaking made this an enjoyable watch. Ferrell does a very solid job. The ending, however, is a total cop-out and ruins the film's spirit.
  • August 12, 2009
    I couldnt sit through the whole movie. It had no humor to me.
  • August 12, 2009
    Not a big fan of Will Farrel, but this movie is alright!!!

Summary


Stranger Than Fiction Summary