Critic Reviews
-
Derek Adams, Time Out
Essentially about loss, guilt and regret, Auburn's film also examines Julia's increasingly unhealthy obsession with her surrogate daughter, which gives it an air of uneasy tension that never amounts to much.
-
Alissa Simon, Variety
Auds can see what Auburn was aiming for, but his portrait of grieving and wishful thinking doesn't connect emotionally. He's not helped by Weaver's brittle, unsympathetic perf, which borders on caricature.
-
Angie Errigo, Empire Magazine
An overwrought melodrama with bold intentions but poor execution.
-
Wendy Ide, Times [UK]
The film stretches credibility a little with the coincidences that could yet make Louise the missing girl, but gives the actors plenty to work with.
-
Cath Clarke, Guardian [UK]
while there is a lot to like in Auburn's tightly focused film, it never fully pulls together.
-
Elliott Noble, Sky Movies
Auburn leaves too many dramatic holes and blows his potentially explosive 'Festen' moment by allowing a confrontation over dinner to fizzle into anti-climax.
-
Christopher Tookey, Daily Mail [UK]
The kindest adjectives to describe Weaver's performance would be 'overwrought' and 'unsympathetic'.
-
Nigel Andrews, Financial Times
Weaver's still unresolved grief, subtly hits every note that Changeling plinked or plonked like a honky-tonk hokum artist.
-
Anthony Quinn, Independent
There's a prissy self-congratulation about early parts of David Auburn's family-bereavement drama, though it got to me eventually.
-
Derek Malcolm, This is London
It is not without its problems, but this is, at the very least, an attention-grabbing first feature with a fine example of ensemble playing from its cast.
-
Matthew Turner, ViewLondon
Impressively directed, sharply written and emotionally involving drama with a terrific central performance from Sigourney Weaver.
-
Anton Bitel, Film4
Wryly amusing, achingly poignant and pleasingly understated, with a stand-out performance from Weaver.
-
David Nusair, Reel Film Reviews
...a sporadically overwrought but mostly compelling film...
Read all 13 critic reviews
Featured Audience Ratings
-
Sigourney plays a woman who is haunted by the disappearance of her daughter from the park when she was 3 years old. She helps a troubled young girl and convinces herself that she is her long lost daughter. Good cast.
-
Enjoyed this, much to my surprise! After the picky mood I have been in with films today, I really couldn't see a film about a missing child doing it for me when I couldn't even get interested in a film starring Amanda Seyfried. I only really pulled this out as I had been… More
Enjoyed this, much to my surprise! After the picky mood I have been in with films today, I really couldn't see a film about a missing child doing it for me when I couldn't even get interested in a film starring Amanda Seyfried. I only really pulled this out as I had been leant this dvd a while ago and needed to return it. I figured I would put it on for a few minutes, then move onto the next one in the pile. At least I could say I gave it a go, right?
Amazingly this story really did suck me in. It is by no means fast paced, or especially exciting, just a quiet little film about a women who's chid is abducted, and how she has gotten on with her life for 16 years never knowing what happened to her daughter. She meets a troubled young girl named Louise who is the same age her daughter would have been now,and becomes convinced it is her missing Maggie. You don't find out until the end if it is or not, but honestly it barely matters by then. This is a really sweet story about two damaged women and how they help each other. Nicely cast - I was surprised to see Keri Russell is not in this as much as I would have thought (or liked), but Kate Bosworth is really good as Louise - I usually do find her an okay actress, I am not sure why she is so panned all the time. Sigourney looks a little old at the beginning of this film, to have such a young child, but her age works fine in the plus 16 years part. Brandon Sexton I didn't recognise - wow, he has changed!
Not a movie for all I would think, but may well be worth a look if you enjoy dramas.
-
Sigourney Weaver, Kate Bosworth, Alessandro Nivola, David Rasche, Kerri Russell, Elias Koteas
DIRECTED BY: David Auburn
A mother, enduringly traumatized by the disappearance of her three-year old daughter 15 years ago, has cut herself off from her ex-husband and son. However,… More
Sigourney Weaver, Kate Bosworth, Alessandro Nivola, David Rasche, Kerri Russell, Elias Koteas
DIRECTED BY: David Auburn
A mother, enduringly traumatized by the disappearance of her three-year old daughter 15 years ago, has cut herself off from her ex-husband and son. However, when a troubled young woman with a checkered past enters her life, old psychic wounds painfully resurface, as does the illogical and increasingly irrational hope that the young woman may be the daughter she lost so long ago.
If not for the acting of Sigourney Weaver and being a fan of hers that I am, I don't know if I would have finished this movie. It started out really good and I was really interested in where it would go from there. Unfortunately it didn't go very far. It really just never develops. The story had potential. But it just kinda drags out and the ending just wasn't fulfilling for me. There was no closure in the ending. Really wanted to like this movie considering the plot. Just didn't do it for me. But Sigourney does do a great job, and Kate Bosworth was believable.
-
A mother goes to the park with her little daughter. The mother looks away for a short time and her daughter is gone and she can't find her. Years later this mother gets divorced, has a difficult relationship with her son and still clings to the hope of finding her daughter again.… More
A mother goes to the park with her little daughter. The mother looks away for a short time and her daughter is gone and she can't find her. Years later this mother gets divorced, has a difficult relationship with her son and still clings to the hope of finding her daughter again. She then meets a homeless teenage girl and she suspects this is her lost daughter and ends up spending a lot of time with her and trying to make up for all the time she was apart from her. This is a very catching and heartbreaking story. Weaver is at her best in this movie.
-
Weaver plays a mother who completely loses it after the kidnap/abduction of her three year old daughter from the park nearby their house.....her pain is palpable and is extremely unpleasent but a really good film. Dont expect anything but depression after seeing it but it still needs… More
Weaver plays a mother who completely loses it after the kidnap/abduction of her three year old daughter from the park nearby their house.....her pain is palpable and is extremely unpleasent but a really good film. Dont expect anything but depression after seeing it but it still needs to be watched. Her acting is superb....
Currently unavailable on Flixster
Also available on
Other Retailers
Subscription Services
