86%
liked it
Emmy Rossum, Gerard Butler, Jennifer Ellison, Minnie Driver, Miranda Richardson, Patrick Wilson
Based on the hit musical by Andrew Lloyd Webber, the tale tells the story of a disfigured musical genius that haunts the catacombs beneath the Paris Opera, waging a reign of terror over its occupants....( read more
)
Id: 2029362
An exceptional adaptation in terms of both the novel and the musical.
The cast was very pleasing; especially Emmy Rossum. Choosing an actress close to the character's own age was a good move. Usually, the role would be filled by an experienced actress in her late twenties, but 1...( read more)
What an amazing joy ride. The cast was wonderful, they hit them all on the nail. The performances are very memorable and I was very surprised about some of them. Who knew some of them could sing like that? Emmy is so stunning with talent, what a dangerous combination. Butler...wo...( read more)
visually stunning musical epic. however there's nothing more to relish than the visuals. even minnie drivers part is boring in it. the songs are all similar at best
It's sort of like the shot-for-shot remake of Psycho. What's the point? This is just a clumsy, tedious, and altogether inferior version of the great Andrew Lloyd Webber musical.
Amazing! It left me breathless...and wanting more...
(Can't believe that the phantom was Gerard Butler!)
Tragic unrequited love. How sad. I feel bad for the phantom. Even though half his face is scarred he's still kind a hot.
The fantastic sets, costumes, art direction and cinematography make for a wonderful visual spectacle, even though the songs are not altogether great and Butler is a terrible singer.
Gorgeous and touching film. Love the music, love the casting...Shitmaker got lucky here.
