Featured Audience Ratings

• Jeff "

  
  As far as documentary, found footage horror films are concerned, The Poughkeepsie Tapes doesn't offer anything new. I found that this was a bit of a letdown. However I did somewhat enjoy it, but there's really nothing to add in the genre. This film is a collection of things… More
  As far as documentary, found footage horror films are concerned, The Poughkeepsie Tapes doesn't offer anything new. I found that this was a bit of a letdown. However I did somewhat enjoy it, but there's really nothing to add in the genre. This film is a collection of things we've seen time and time again, thus it becomes cliché after cliché. The material here is derivative from Blair Witch Project and there are plenty of opportunities to steer the film in a good direction, however it falls short. The film is decent, but is quite forgettable in the long run. Acting wise, there are no real standout performances and it's standard low-budget acting, so don't expect anything good with that as well. This film has the misfortune of having been made when found footage films started to be hit and miss. This is a decent little flick, but it could have been much better than what it turned out to be. The concept is good and it's a shame that they couldn't deliver a more solid film because of it. The ingredients were there, but it lacked something to truly make this one stand out in the genre. Overall, it's decent, but it's nothing original, thrilling or exciting. The directors clearly don't know how to create a tense, suspenseful horror film, and it leaves a lot to be desired from the final; product. A decent film, but nothing ever special, The Poughkeepsie Tapes could have been much better. Compared to other films in this genre, this one doesn't do anything to truly elevate the genre into new, unexplored territory.

• Stuart B

  
  One of the best serial killer movies I have seen. Using the documentary style of film making to great effect, a chilling and at times horrifying look at a how this guy does what he does and gets away with it. So much better than so many crappy teen slasher movies.

• Eric A

  
  A literally crazy film about a sadistic serial killer. I understand it is a mockumentary, but the filming and visuals could have been better. The acting was also poor, not the greatest of films.

• E.J. B

  
  John Erick Dowdle's unjustly shelved The Poughkeepsie Tapes is not torture porn. It's a terrifying faux documentary that forces you to contemplate the mind of a serial killer. The found footage "genre" has been done. But this film takes it one step further.… More
  John Erick Dowdle's unjustly shelved The Poughkeepsie Tapes is not torture porn. It's a terrifying faux documentary that forces you to contemplate the mind of a serial killer. The found footage "genre" has been done. But this film takes it one step further. Instead of playing the found footage ala [Rec] or The Blair Witch Project, The Poughkeepsie Tapes brings in the reactions of FBI officials, relatives of the victims, psycho analysts, and the like who talk about how the found footage has affected them, and how much thought, patience, cunning, determination, and sheer joy the killer put into his murders. This is not a film for everyone. The way the interviewed describe what is on the found tapes is unsettling. But then, you're forced to watch parts of the tapes. While the build up is scarier than the pay off, both are effective nevertheless. My main complaint is that the script tries to make this serial killer like Jigsaw, which means he's too perfect at what he does. The man has thought out every angle and much to his own satisfaction, he toys with the police. This makes the movie quite predictable. But at the same time, I think the film isn't about how the movie ends. It's an experience that the filmmakers want you to go on, an experience into the most depraved human being civilized society could know.

• A.D. V

  
  There's a few unsettling moments here and there but really this is nothing more than Forensic Files-The Movie except it's embarrassingly obvious that the whole thing is fake with horrible acting and worse dialogue.

• Brian D

  
  Nasty and unpleasant movie told in POV and documentary style not original but works all the same. Gore hounds will be disappointed as there not much blood or guts but its the violence and torture displayed and same out of camera view that makes it all to disturbing.My main problem is… More
  Nasty and unpleasant movie told in POV and documentary style not original but works all the same. Gore hounds will be disappointed as there not much blood or guts but its the violence and torture displayed and same out of camera view that makes it all to disturbing.My main problem is some of the acting was abit lame and spoiled the so called based on real events.Over all there a great 70/80's style to this with great use to the shoddy camera work that the killer used and the music used in the film give me the creeps.

• Wahida K

  
  Well Some Movies based upon real events get mixed with the real evidence. I think here is the case. Long time ago I saw a Movie, later learned it wasnt a Movie it it was real. Well I dont know much about the PughKeepsie Tapes events but I know that stuff like this shouldnt be… More
  Well Some Movies based upon real events get mixed with the real evidence. I think here is the case. Long time ago I saw a Movie, later learned it wasnt a Movie it it was real. Well I dont know much about the PughKeepsie Tapes events but I know that stuff like this shouldnt be expected with a "Happy End" like those movies based upon serial killers. Some times the Directors show the Audience authentic stuff just with different Faces.

• jd c

  
  I believe if you were to give Ted Bundy a video camera at the age of 14 and tell him to direct a movie you'd have something like The Poughkeepsie Tapes. What we have here is a film(if you can even call it that) with a bunch of sick ideas, but it's put together in the works… More
  I believe if you were to give Ted Bundy a video camera at the age of 14 and tell him to direct a movie you'd have something like The Poughkeepsie Tapes. What we have here is a film(if you can even call it that) with a bunch of sick ideas, but it's put together in the works of a child. There is no skill here, but simply just an idea as horrifying as Gary M. Heidnik's psyche results, but filmed by a man who seemingly never watched a documentary film in his life. Being that low attention spans can do this to you I'll try expressing some compassion for this hack and focus more on shitty casting directors. I mean someone needs to be blamed for this mess other than John E. Dowdle, director of Poughkeepsie Tapes, and since the actors were tolerant enough to put up with this atrocity I'll respectably lay off and center my accusations on the casting director, assuming he was on Nitrous Oxide at the time. I have seen better performances in a porno film. Oddly it sometimes takes one person to break the stride of a group related disaster, which is why I'm surprised no one on set told Dowdle he was in the middle of making a shit-bomb almost worse than a Disney version of August Underground's Mordum. But who's really to blame? Yes, at times The Poughkeepsie Tapes can be utterly disturbing, but only because there's a true idea of a psychopathic lifestyle on display here. It's too bad the killer seems too much like the actual actor failing to desperately play the killer. It's fu*king embarrassing to watch, and the sad part is it's mostly performed behind a camera. This pitiful display of overdramatized behavior shows the actor's talentless ability through his vocals alone! I really hope no one hires this guy to do the next voice over in Shrek, otherwise we'll have riots with hundreds of little disappointed children. Nothing in The Poughkeepsie Tapes is believable because of this. For those looking for something extreme, in fact even more extreme, I suggest reading from the crime library instead(www.trutv.com/library/crime/). It's much more in depth, and it's actually "true", without any shitty acting or dialogue(which is almost worse than the acting) to ruin your guilty pleasures. And for those looking for an actual Snuff film, well...good luck! You can start your journey by searching for the Paul and Karla Homolka film tapes. On a higher note, some visuals in The Poughkeepsie Tapes are truly effective and creepy, and it's followed by a chilling score throughout. The most standout out of spine tingling moments for me would be the killer's "spiderwalk" toward the ending, and the victim who's forced to slash another victim. The last interview in the movie(with the main victim) is also the film's high point. It's a deeply sad and heart shattering moment that sends a chill indeed. Yes, it had it's moments! BUT, it wasn't enough to save it from it's mess. Horrbile acting, an atrociously lame script, and plot holes up the ass. What could have truly been something turned out to be pretty much nothing. The Poughkeepsie Tapes is a film that has "potential" written all over it. As bad as it is though, there were quite some scenes that chilled me enough to give this 2 stars. Other than that there was nothing. Just an empty mess with the smell of a turd to weigh it down. Boo hoo. Hopefully "Quarantine" will change my image of John E. Dowdle. Sometimes we're entitled a second chance.

• Luke B

  
  As a mockumentary it is an absolute failure. This is because it is never believable, killings would never be shown in such a film and the acting was poor and obviously scripted. Also why would a real documentary start with somebody asking "Are you filming?". The only reason… More
  As a mockumentary it is an absolute failure. This is because it is never believable, killings would never be shown in such a film and the acting was poor and obviously scripted. Also why would a real documentary start with somebody asking "Are you filming?". The only reason this would have to be done would be to establish that it WAS a documentary, which no documentary needs to do. Some of the scenes are disturbing and I think the film should have just been shot through the killers eyes. The cheapness also leads to some poorly handled and offensive digs at 9/11 and victims of such crimes. Obvious in its twists and turns which dampen the effects of the truly chilling moments, such as the weird double mask walk.

• ken j

  
  When a bunch of boxes containing what seems to be a endless amount of video tapes is found inside a abandoned house little do cops know that on these tapes is the decade long reign of a very violent and sick serial killer thats the starting off point for this Mockumentary that follows… More
  When a bunch of boxes containing what seems to be a endless amount of video tapes is found inside a abandoned house little do cops know that on these tapes is the decade long reign of a very violent and sick serial killer thats the starting off point for this Mockumentary that follows the story of a brutal killer that liked to violently torture his victims in many different ways. This was a hard movie to review cause it had alot of good points and also alot of bad i enjoyed it for the most part and would recommend it for a one time watch the story if interesting but the acting could have been more believeable for me.

• Christopher B

  
  I didn't know whether audiences would ever see this one. I remember it being advertised over a year ago, then disappearing completely. Maybe it would have worked better back then, though I doubt it. A fake documentary on a brilliant serial killer who is always several steps… More
  I didn't know whether audiences would ever see this one. I remember it being advertised over a year ago, then disappearing completely. Maybe it would have worked better back then, though I doubt it. A fake documentary on a brilliant serial killer who is always several steps ahead of the authorities is interesting, but not engrossing. I was waiting for some kind of revelation, some new development that would make it go beyond just a make believe serial killer, but it wasn't to come. It was rather disappointing that I had to view the torture and deaths and then in the end, there was really nothing to them. Just, "Boy is this serial killer ever smart". Whoop-de-do. Still, it's well made and as long as your hopes aren't high it's moderately entertaining, though not one of the better serial killer mockumentaries.

Read all 11 featured audience ratings