Featured Audience Ratings

• Melvin W

  
  Holmes: We all have occasional failures. Fortunately Dr. Watson never writes about mine.  "My private life is my own affair." The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes is a interesting and thoroughly entertaining mystery from the great Billy Wilder. The first half hour is about… More
  Holmes: We all have occasional failures. Fortunately Dr. Watson never writes about mine.  "My private life is my own affair." The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes is a interesting and thoroughly entertaining mystery from the great Billy Wilder. The first half hour is about as much into the private life of Sherlock Holmes as you'll get. The title is a little misleading because this is still a standard Holmes picture. Wilder just added some confusion about Holmes sexuality and the idea that when Holmes is not busy on a case, he likes to indulge in cocaine. After that there is no real difference plot wise, to any other Sherlock Holmes movie, except this better than average. Holmes is bored with no case to take his interest. Then one night a woman arrives at his doorstep. Apparently an attempt was just made on her life, and now she doesn't know much about herself. The next morning she remembers everything. She came to Holmes for him to help her find her husband. This mystery takes us to Scotland and involves a variety of weird things like the Loch Ness monster, midgets and canaries.  The performance by Robert Stephens as Sherlock Holmes is spot on. He portrays the detective brilliantly. Then there's Colin Blakely who is an admirable Dr. Watson, and the iconic Christopher Lee as Sherlock's brother. The plot is pretty cool, with weird occurrences adding to the mystery of the case.  The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes is fun throughout and sporadically funny. Wilder's witty touch is perfect for a Sherlock Holme's film. I was a little disappointed this didn't dive more into the personal life of Holme's, but as a straight detective story, it is a damn good one.

• Byron B

  
  I've only seen a few of the older, black & white, more sinister Sherlock Holmes movies. I enjoyed the occasional laughs this story provided and how Wilder was unafraid to show some aspects of Sherlock Holmes that were not traditionally portrayed. In the special features on… More
  I've only seen a few of the older, black & white, more sinister Sherlock Holmes movies. I enjoyed the occasional laughs this story provided and how Wilder was unafraid to show some aspects of Sherlock Holmes that were not traditionally portrayed. In the special features on my DVD I learned that Wilder and Diamond intended the movie to be in four parts, four mysteries Watson had supposedly locked up and not revealed to the public during his life. The movie was too long so the original full length preface describing this had to be scrapped as well as two of the mysteries and a flashback segment. As the movie stands today, Clive Revill is a Russian ballerina's assistant who sends for Holmes and his services in the first part. The services required are not what you'd expect, but then this is a Billy Wilder movie and you shouldn't expect the sort of mysteries of the old days. The second larger part is closer to a traditional mystery and brings Genevieve as Ms. Valladon into the picture. She provides a good steady third leg to Stephens as Sherlock and Blakely as the Doctor for the majority of the film. Christopher Lee also appears as Sherlock's brother Mycroft who works for the government and adds ambivalence to whether Her Majesty's government may be involved in a cover up. The three main characters follow the clues to Scotland and a few castles around Loch Ness. The ending with Queen Victoria is satirical, but pretty silly. Still it is a fun movie with great production values recreating the time period!

• Stephen E

  
  It seems like Billy Wilder can do no wrong when it comes to filmmaking; "The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes" stands out as his most supremely underrated work. A film of wonderful performances, offbeat humor and intriguing mystery, "The Private Life of Sherlock… More
  It seems like Billy Wilder can do no wrong when it comes to filmmaking; "The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes" stands out as his most supremely underrated work. A film of wonderful performances, offbeat humor and intriguing mystery, "The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes" unfolds at a very deliberate pace, taking close to forty minutes to actually get started. Robert Stephens and Colin Blakely give us without question the best cinematic representation of the flamboyant detective and his knowledgeable companion, each delivering lively, nuanced performances. It has been said that "The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes" was originally intended to run close to around three hours long, but due to studio interference, it was cut down and excess footage was lost. What a shame: there's no telling how grand that three hour version might have been.

• Sunil J

  
  As a huge Sherlock Holmes fan I really had high hopes for this one. Major disappointment. The cast was fine, the overall concept was interesting, the script was fair, and the result was the equivalent of a gay Sherlock Holmes SNL skit stretched to over 2 hours. I'm somewhat… More
  As a huge Sherlock Holmes fan I really had high hopes for this one. Major disappointment. The cast was fine, the overall concept was interesting, the script was fair, and the result was the equivalent of a gay Sherlock Holmes SNL skit stretched to over 2 hours. I'm somewhat baffled at these critical reviews.

• Alice S

  
  Would you be willing to know Sherlock Holmes's dark side? Or, better said... would you care to meet a less aristocratic, but more human and more fun Holmes? If you ever wondered, you now have the opportunity to find out who Sherlock Holmes really is, which is his past, what are… More
  Would you be willing to know Sherlock Holmes's dark side? Or, better said... would you care to meet a less aristocratic, but more human and more fun Holmes? If you ever wondered, you now have the opportunity to find out who Sherlock Holmes really is, which is his past, what are his relationships with Watson, how he works and what he does when he has nothing to do ... also, you will know Sherlock's brother, Mycroft, and Ilse Hoffmansthal, a German spy whose true intentions Sherlock fails to figure out but who ends up as his romantic interest (surprisingly?), all packed with a logical explanation for the Loch Ness monster's apparitions. Of course, seems to make fun as much as make a tribute, but what does it matter as long as it does it well?

• Anastasia B

  
  A bit of a slow follow-up to a raving start, this movie proves why Billy Wilder is still considered to be one of the masters. It's thoroughly entertaining, not afraid to provoke, and still has elements of surprise in it (well, most of the time, anyway). If you love Billy Wilder… More
  A bit of a slow follow-up to a raving start, this movie proves why Billy Wilder is still considered to be one of the masters. It's thoroughly entertaining, not afraid to provoke, and still has elements of surprise in it (well, most of the time, anyway). If you love Billy Wilder you don't want to miss this film. On the plus side, also, the appearance of Christopher Lee as Holmes' brother. For those who don't know, Lee played Holmes in " Sherlock Holmes and the Deadly Necklace" a few years back, in 1962.

• Tom S

  
  This movie combined Sherlock Holmes, La Folia, Billy Wilder, The Loch Ness monster, and midgets--five of my favorite things--and still I was underwhelmed.

Read all 7 featured audience ratings