Available Online

Rotten Tomatoes Score: 95%

Critic Reviews from Rotten Tomatoes

"It is in large part old-fashioned, in that it's mile-wide and ancient-history Sherlock Holmes, but it's also handsomely produced and directed with incisiveness by Wilder."
‑ Variety Staff, Variety
"Before the movie is 20 minutes old, Wilder has settled for simply telling a Sherlock Holmes adventure."
‑ Roger Ebert, Chicago Sun-Times
"The plotting is weak, and ill-served by the movie's generally lackadaisical approach; but the dialogue is witty, and Wilder and Diamond get a lot of mileage out of the idea that Sherlock Holmes is as fragile as he is brilliant."
‑ Noel Murray, The Dissolve
"This unjustly forgotten Billy Wilder film takes on the much-loved character of Sherlock Holmes and attempts to humanize him by examining his vulnerabilities."
‑ , TV Guide's Movie Guide
"Billy Wilder's psychological angle on Holmes is compelling."
‑ Steve Crum, Video-Reviewmaster.com
"A wonderful, cruelly underrated film."
‑ Geoff Andrew, Time Out
"The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes is comparatively mild Billy Wilder and rather daring Sherlock Holmes, not a perfect mix, perhaps, but a fond and entertaining one."
‑ Vincent Canby, New York Times
"This existing version is still fascinating, funny and clever."
‑ Jeffrey M. Anderson, Combustible Celluloid
"A true evocation of the spirit of the Strand Magazine, this is the best Holmes movie ever made and sorely underrated in the Wilder canon."
‑ Kim Newman, Empire Magazine
"Wilder's after something more profound than a simple mystery tale here and to a large extent he succeeds in his quest to cast the man in relief when held up against The Legend"
‑ Jeremy Heilman, MovieMartyr.com
"Wilder's second most underrated masterpiece."
‑ Andrew Sarris, New York Observer
"Affectionately conceived, chock-full of marvelous subtleties, this meticulously constructed adventure-romance shouldn't be missed."
‑ Don Druker, Chicago Reader
"Billy Wilder's endearingly romantic The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes is...worth seeing just for Alexandre Trauner's sets, especially a magical Baker Street."
‑ , Guardian
"Stage actor Robert Stephens brilliantly plays Holmes with a nod and a wink."
‑ Dennis Schwartz, Ozus' World Movie Reviews
"The setup is brilliant. The central mystery -- concerning the Loch Ness Monster -- is less rewarding, and its shaggy sea-monster solution somewhat less than that."
‑ Ken Hanke, Mountain Xpress (Asheville, NC)
More reviews for The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes on Rotten Tomatoes