Critic Reviews
-
Stephen Whitty, Newark Star-Ledger
It's not honest with its people, or its plot. And the only ones it really cheats are audience members.
-
Jeannette Catsoulis, New York Times
[Jackson's] doleful revenant is in almost every scene, and this hardworking actor seems to know that the film around him should be a light-footed caper instead of a grim noir with a side order of deviance.
-
Rick Groen, Globe and Mail
A scripted cliché: the ex-con who wants to go straight until the plot kicks in.
-
Kyle Smith, New York Post
"The Samaritan" proves that even Samuel L. Jackson can be boring.
-
Mark Olsen, Los Angeles Times
The haphazard feeling of the narrative deflates any real tension.
-
Elizabeth Weitzman, New York Daily News
Way too much psychosexual melodrama, portrayed in performances that range from utterly bored (Jackson) to embarrassingly broad (Kirby).
-
Todd Jorgenson, Cinemalogue.com
What could have been an intriguing character study about redemption turns into an absurd series of eye-rolling plot twists that makes it impossible to take this mess seriously.
-
Annlee Ellingson, Paste Magazine
Director David Weaver and co-writer Elan Mastai's neo-noir script is just a shadow of the genre.
-
Diego Costa, Slant Magazine
It packs its narrative with a succession of increasingly clichéd twists, one of which involves the sudden recognition that its main character, Foley (Samuel L. Jackson), is romantically involved with his own daughter.
-
Robert Levin, Film School Rejects
The experience of watching Samuel L. Jackson actually act is the only real pleasure to be gleaned from the movie.
-
Kurt Loder, Reason Online
Even the spirited Ruth Negga can't lift this by-the-numbers neo-noir out of its dull parboiled rut.
-
Norman Wilner, NOW Toronto
Director David Weaver and co-writer Elan Mastai twist the movie in several different directions before settling for a professional but generic pulp thriller.
-
Jim Slotek, Jam! Movies
It seems impossible that Jackson could go through an entire movie without ever raising his voice, but here he is.
-
Alison Willmore, Movieline
The Samaritan takes a jarring turn right out of Park Chan-wook, and from there takes a tumble into ludicrousness from which it doesn't recover.
-
Brian Orndorf, BrianOrndorf.com
It's thoroughly mediocre, which feels like such a disappointment when one considers that the script's ingredients include murder, deception, sex, and ungodly sin.
-
Sam Adams, AV Club
Jackson seems only interested in cashing his paycheck, even if it's not an especially large one.
-
Chris Barsanti, Film Journal International
...goes from mechanical to (unintentionally) hilarious, stopping frequently at the cliché shop along the way.
Read all 17 critic reviews
Featured Audience Ratings
-
<b><I>The Samaritan</b></I> has to be one of the worse films SLJ has starred in. The script, acting, directing, and even the little bit of action was all bad. Then the big reveal of who Foley and Iris are to each other after everything they did made me… More
<b><I>The Samaritan</b></I> has to be one of the worse films SLJ has starred in. The script, acting, directing, and even the little bit of action was all bad. Then the big reveal of who Foley and Iris are to each other after everything they did made me absolutely sick. I was completely disturbed that Iris knew and continued to do the things she did with him. It's a film I will for sure avoid in the future.
-
A gritty and crisp serving of a thriller that`s twisty, enthralling and very entertaining. It delivers up some solid suspense and great performances from its cast. It stays true to the tradition of the old-school drifter films of the day and serves it up again like its fresh and new.… More
A gritty and crisp serving of a thriller that`s twisty, enthralling and very entertaining. It delivers up some solid suspense and great performances from its cast. It stays true to the tradition of the old-school drifter films of the day and serves it up again like its fresh and new. A slick, brutal and sharp piece of film noir. Director, David Weaver crafts an exceptional and hard-boiled film. Samuel L. Jackson delivers a compelling and rock solid performance, it turns to be one of his best film roles in years. It truly separates him from what we have been used to seeing him in the last few years and gladly welcome him back to genre films once again. Tom Wilkonson is terrific. Luke Kirby and Ruth Negga are excellent, A real slice of Pulp Fiction that echos with Oldboy.
-
You've got to know a secret to tell a secret.
Good movie! This film represents a dying breed of crime thriller in which character and plot take precedence over action and special effects. It could have drowned in a sea of car chases, shootouts, brutal fistfights, and even gore.… More
You've got to know a secret to tell a secret.
Good movie! This film represents a dying breed of crime thriller in which character and plot take precedence over action and special effects. It could have drowned in a sea of car chases, shootouts, brutal fistfights, and even gore. Whatever we do see in those respects is used only when absolutely necessary. That's good when those moments finally happen, they will elicit authentic shock and excitement from the audience. No one will be numb from scene after scene of mindless violence and choreography. All in all, it was a thoroughly entertaining flick which is worth a watch.
After twenty years in prison, Foley is finished with the grifter's life. When he meets an elusive young woman named Iris, the possibility of a new start looks real. But his past is proving to be a stubborn companion.
-
The Samaritan is just simply too derivative, too cliche, and too much in love with the style of a film noir rather than creating an honest portrayal of characters at crossroads. Samuel L Jackson plays Foley, an ex-grifter who has just got out of a 25-year sentence for murdering his… More
The Samaritan is just simply too derivative, too cliche, and too much in love with the style of a film noir rather than creating an honest portrayal of characters at crossroads. Samuel L Jackson plays Foley, an ex-grifter who has just got out of a 25-year sentence for murdering his best friend. Foley is simply trying to live his life, get a legit job, and spend his nights at a local bar feeling sorry for himself. That is until Ethan, the son of the man Foley killed, comes to him with a "one last job" offer. Despite pulling one major twist, the plot consistently treads familiar territory.
The performances are restrained but not in a good way. Everybody here seems completely bored, as if they're looking forward to a nice tidy paycheck more so than a solid performance.
Furthermore, the piano based soundtrack attempts to create a very sad, melancholic tone for the picture, but it quickly starts to feel very monotonous. Combined with an uninteresting visual style where everything seems filmed under gold filters, The Samaritan just treads along in a meandering fashion that never manages to engage. Its minor twists aren't enough to make up for a story that we've seen way too many times before.
-
The Samaritan is both a meditative noir film, and a pulpy action thriller. It does a good job handling its set-up, not being afraid to slowly develop its characters, giving Samuel L. Jackson a complex role, of which he delivers a strong performance. It also features some good work by… More
The Samaritan is both a meditative noir film, and a pulpy action thriller. It does a good job handling its set-up, not being afraid to slowly develop its characters, giving Samuel L. Jackson a complex role, of which he delivers a strong performance. It also features some good work by Tom Wilkinson, always a formidable screen presence. The script does a generally good job with its plot twists, and has a number of good dialogue exchanges. What hinders the film, however, is a sloppily executed final act, with ridiculous turns and a hasty resolution. On the whole, however, there's more substance to The Samaritan than its limited budget and release would indicate, not quite an "A" noir piece, but better than a low-level "B" pulp action entry.
3.5/5 Stars
Currently unavailable on Flixster
Also available on
Other Retailers
Subscription Services