Andy On, Ka Tung Lam, Louis Koo

The post-1997 world of Chinese rule means that even the long-established Wo Shing Triad Society must change its ways and think north. But after the brotherhood was fractured by the ruthless grip of Ch...( read more  read more... )airman Lok, it was up to the younger generation to lead the way. Jimmy is the perfect candidate: smart and entrepreneurial. Even the Chinese authorities are interested in what Jimmy has to offer. Only problem is, Chairman Lok isn't one who gives up power easily.

Flixster Users

79% liked it

4,953 ratings

Critics

96% liked it

46 critics

Unrated, 1 hr. 32 min.

Directed by: Johnny To

Release Date: April 25, 2007

Invite friends to see

DVD Release Date: September 18, 2007

Stats: 307 reviews

Get movie widget Recommend it Add to Favorites

Your Rating



clear rating

Flixster Reviews (307)


  • October 5, 2009
    hardcore sequel to johnny to's election, even more brutal and bloody and every bit as badass. the heir apparent to john woo and hk gangster classics, minus the sentimentality
  • August 6, 2009
    much better than the 1st part. you can understand it all!!! gripping, violent, sublime! i think the action and the elements of story are well paced compared to the 1st also. we have a little story then a little bit of action and then some story, some action... yes, i think the tw...( read more)o johnny to films must be seen as companion pieces to be fully appreciated. do not watch one and not the other. it is close to the godfather films if not on even terms
  • January 21, 2009
    It's no surprise that director Johnny To is a fan of Francis Ford Coppola, but the influence is used wisely in the sequel to Election about an underground society maintaining a balance and order among the brotherhood.

    There are quite a handful of characters in the film, so som...( read more)e may be confused initially about the relationships between them. It definitely helps if you have caught the first film. There are a few side plots which may confuse the uninitiated, even more, but if you pay close attention to the relationships of the characters, it won't be too hard to follow along. Triad Election is not about the violence, but the slow burn leading to it. There is no hurry to get to the end, as Triad takes its time telling the story. Triad Election is a great gangster flick. Its slow pacing allows the characters to develop and the violence to remain an undertone. However, when it does happen, it's so brutal, you don't know who to root for.
    Photobucket
  • February 26, 2008
    In Triad Election's most memorable scene, a kidnapped gangmember is beaten to death with a sledgehammer by members of a rival gang, then delimbed with a butcher knife, put through a meat grinder, and fed to caged dogs. After this long, sickening ordeal, Johnnie To cuts to ...( read more)a shot of a pile of blood-soaked cash on the floor; the symbolism's a little heavy-handed but, for a film about the parity between criminals, politicians and businessmen, essential.

    Photobucket

    Set where capitalism, democracy and crooks intersect, Triad Election, the stand-alone sequel to To's previous film, Election, is, narratively, simple enough. The Wo Sing Society, one of Hong Kong's most important Triads, is having its biennial leadership election and Lok (Simon Yam), the current chairman, is running for a second term against the charismatic Jimmy (Louis Koo). Though Jimmy wants to become a legitimate businessman and cut-off his ties to the crimeworld, he is coerced by the government to enter the race; they prefer his level-headedness to Lok's mercuriality, and won't let him do business if he doesn't do what they say. The elections bring out the worst in both sides, as an amicable relationship ("everyone looks up to you", Lok tells Jimmy early on, presumably including himself) turns sour in light of their competition; a string of increasingly brutal kidnappings and killings ensue, each leader surrendering any ethical sense they may have once possessed for the goal of victory. With power and money on the line, anything goes.

    It's a film swimming in melancholia, from its dominantly brown and black color scheme to the deliberate pacing, patient editing, and melancholic soundtrack. In essence, Triad Election is a string of brilliant set pieces, alternatingly violent, tense, and funnier that you'd expect; like some other recent Asian genre films (Infernal Affairs, Memories of Murder), it escapes from feeling contrived despite its clear American influences, by nailing the essence of the crime picture while sprinkling fresh flourishes in the margins. If Triad Election were an English-language film, it'd be Number One at the American Box Office and racking up Oscars - which, go figure, was exactly what happened the last time a HK production was remade by Americans.

    Sometimes you have to see a lesser film to enjoy a better one. That's the case with To's Election / Triad Election double feauture. The first's dense drama gives context to the more energizing, intricate, intriguingly political sequel. Still, Triad Election is arguably more a remake of its predecessor than a sequel. The second can be easily watched without the first, which is good, although I'd still recommend to watch both in a row which, for me, was quite a cinematic experience.

    While Triad Election's message about the stain that power leaves on men's souls is a little overfamiliar, To supports it with an unbroken string of well-observed, well-acted scenes where rich villains fight for position and try to maintain the illusion that they're just trying to build a better life for their families. Triad Election echoes The Godfather Part II, "The Sopranos", and Goodfellas, but it's resolutely a Chinese story, reaching back to the origins of Hong Kong crime syndicates, and showing how they struggle to keep a foothold in a modernized world. To covers it all, from the residuals of tradition to the new technological wonderland where citizens still live in fear of bird flu. Like the best crime stories, this one isn't about how the bad guys live, it's about how we live.
  • September 4, 2007
    Is this a sequel?? Sequels have a reputation for being a bit undone after their predecessors, but in true Godfather fashion, instead this is a marvelous continuation of the story, a sequel worthy of the first.

    Two years have passed, and a new election is looming. Jimmy Lee (Lou...( read more)is Koo) is the Wo Shing's top earner, giving him the respect and power due to his business savvy and idealism. But deep down, Jimmy just wants to live his life, and move away from the Triad society. But Chinese Intelligence and a few Triad veterans have other plans for Jimmy, believing he is next in line to lead the Wo Shing, despite his protests.

    Lok (Simon Yam) returns and seeks an historic second term as Chairman, his cunning and devious mind begins to play politics amongst the groups, and soon engages in war with Jimmy as the fight and blood spills onto the streets of Hong Kong.


    This is more bloody, brutal, and it sure does let your imagination run wild as the violence is sure to leave a even the most hardened and desensitized movie goer a little shaken..... the movie does move quicker than the original, but thats due to the fact the the introduction has been told in Election, and Election 2 delves deeper into the emotions and feelings of the central characters and increases the tensions and violence to a new level.

    The original cast (minus Tony Leung Ka Fi - tis a shame) return and it feels like old home week - by this point if you really enjoyed Election, it would be like seeing familiar faces and persons again. This movie is essentially Louis Koo's flick, taking the major role, though Simon Yam did take a step back, he played it out well, his screen time mixed with power games and his troubled relationship with his son, while Jimmy tries to balance his business and social life with his newly married wife, while trying to maintain his status and power within the Triad.

    Its an all out blood fest, and as they say, only the strong survive. But this one goes far deeper than just criminal politics....

    Music score, camera and directing work all top notch, nothing strays from the quality of the first movie.

    I guess the only criticism is maybe the movie was a bit too short, it could have been drawn out a bit more, and cold have had more tension and be a bit more gripping like the first. I think the action scenes replaced some of the drama and tension, and that kinda lets it down.


    Yes, worth watching!! Winner of Best Film - Hong Kong Film Critics Awards, Official selection in the various prestigious film festivals, and nominations all around.

    But other than that, a definite sequel worth watching!!
  • July 5, 2009
    Straight up, badass. More cruel than action and more political than anything else, it raises issues of Hong Kong in such a grisly fashion that it probably makes more than one of 'em come out feeling queasy at the whole thought. I found this great and the leading lady, not so lead...( read more)ing as the males dominated the show, was pretty hot.
  • June 25, 2009
    FIlm number 2 and I follow it with the sequel.

    Not much to say except that it is more of the same.
    Usually, that isn't a good thing but when you have a cast that is as interesting as this and so many possibilties with all of them, it would be a shame to not explore their world a...( read more) little more.

    Following on from the first film, this takes a look at when someone can't let go of power. Like before, this is a film that explores the people and their whys.

    In the first film, it was the difference in methods that the film revolved around; the choice between two paths. Here, it is about the proverbial changing of the guard; when the younger generation is more suited to the new world than the old hands are.

    I am not usually a fan of Louis Koo but for some reason, his trademark woodeness seems to fit his role as the not entirely comfortable usurper. In a rare moment of genius, not letting him have too many lines and simply letting his carry out his actions makes his character that little bit more interesting and goes a long way to highlight his "just do it" attitude.
    There is even a wordless MacBeth moment of no return that was quite brilliant (although bloody).
  • April 14, 2009
    this was better than the 1st one. but still there is not been fierd one singel gun-shot during all theese movies. its hard to image a gangster movie without some being killed by a gun!
  • March 25, 2009
    Second part of the ambitious 20th century majesty of To,a humongous presumption of events occurs 2 years later.Triads are coming to an end (fictional that is,hehe).What better way to celebrate it by swaying in a brilliant choreography of little scenarios and exceptional violence?...( read more)The heir of Woo rest assure all of you directs the mob in all its fiendish glory,in spite of it being minor to the first part.
  • February 15, 2009
    I think I was expecting something scores more dramatic but this is a solid Triad film. Louis Koo is so handsome, I'm glad he was in this and that he's still working.

Critic Reviews


August 24, 2007
Ty Burr, Boston Globe

The film's violence erupts in rare, staccato bursts, all the more horrifying for coming out of nowhere. full review

May 31, 2007
Colin Covert, The Minneapolis Star Tribune

Triad Election is slow-burning and sedate, even dull in stretches. But it deserves credit for presenting such a courageous critique of the Chinese system, which combines the worst aspects of official ... full review

View more Triad Election (Hak se wui yi wo wai kwai) reviews at RottenTomatoes.com

Comments


  • ualush
    October 20, 2007
    Warning for the newly released Tartan Asia Extreme version, I've read that the subtitles are about 5secs behind the voice. So the next person is talking before the last ones dialog is shown. Really a shame for such a higher profile release.

Critic ratings and reviews powered by RottenTomatoes.com

Fresh (60% or more critics rated the movie positively)

Rotten (59% or fewer critics rated the movie positively)

More Like This


Click a thumb to vote on that suggestion, or add your own suggestions.

  • Election (Hak se wui)
    Election (Hak se wui) (88%)
  • GoodFellas
    GoodFellas (20%)
  • The Departed
    The Departed (36%)
  • Fireworks (Hana-bi)
    Fireworks (Hana-bi) (0%)

Facts


No facts approved yet. Be the first

Triad Election (H... : Watch Free on TV


Triad Election (Hak se wui yi wo wai kwai) Trivia

Movie Quizzes


No quizzes for Triad Election (Hak se wui yi wo wai kwai). Want to create one?

Video Clips


No video clips yet. Want to upload one?

Recent News


No recent headlines. Got one?

Most Popular Skin