Yankee Doodle Dandy

• 
  
  July 3, 2008

  rubystevens

  i know it's corny but i love this film and if you haven't seen cagney dance you're in for a treat.

  Share This Review
• 
  
  February 17, 2008

  sanjurosamurai

  this is a genuine musical masterpiece. one of the best films i have ever seen and certainly near the top of the great musicals, this film is a deep tale of patriotism and achievement. the film follows cohans life with perfect pace and a high level of engagement. we see the cha...( read more)racter grow as a person and develop powerfully. there are striking similarities with citizen kane released a year earlier, but i actually enjoyed this film more than that one. cagney recieved a best actor oscar for his role and he deserved it in one of his many great performances. the music was perfect and well placed, striking out against the idea that a musical has to be mostly music. a great classic. "my mother thanks you, my father thanks you, my sister thanks you, and i thank you."

  Share This Review
• 
  
  October 26, 2007

  FangsFirst

  I was, well, not TERRIBLY recently, but somewhat recently, admonished by my father for the gaping holes in my collection when it comes to musicals, as he is quite a fan of them himself. I'll admit that in most of my life I have not been a fan. I am particularly loathe to associat...( read more)e with the sort where characters burst out randomly into song without context during the plot to convey the story forward. I have difficulty accepting this outside of animation, except in instances where it's fitting for an odd tone for a film--the obvious example (one which perhaps proves that conditional exception) is my long-time love for the 1986 musical Little Shop of Horrors--but that could also be tied to my affection for 60s "girl groups."
  
  Going backward through film as I have been in the past year or two, though, I've discovered a fairly large number of films that don't approach musicals in that fashion which is much more suited to my taste. When it's a musical number even inside the movie, what issue is there to take, unless the song itself is unpleasant? Now, I've also found that that approach bothers me a lot less than it used to, and I think I was bothered far more by the songs and overall plots (as musicals can have that tendency toward the syrupy sweet) than by that process.
  
  But that's moot because this is a movie about an author of musicals--George M. Cohan, author of songs like "You're a Grand Old Flag," "Over There," and "Give My Regards to Broadway." As such, the songs occur as songs that George is writing or has written, or in snippets of in-play performances. I suppose this is a sort of indirect violation if you indeed do not like characters bursting into song, but here it's an actor playing an actor playing a character bursting into song, which is different in its way. Cohan is played by James Cagney, and he earned an Oscar for the role. I first saw Cagney as a part of an introduction to film class in Angels with Dirty Faces, and instantly liked him a lot. Much like Bogart, he just has a magnetic charisma that just instantly makes what he's doing and saying interesting. It's such an instinctual reaction that I'm not sure I can explain it any better than that. That role, however, is the kind Cagney is most known for (as encompassed by the infamous--and non-existent--line, "You dirty rat!") but I've heard since that he thought of himself far more as a song-and-dance man than a gangster, even if he found himself almost constantly relegated to such a role. Here you can just barely see why--he's a fantastic dancer. This wonderfully loose-legged sort of style he pulls out throughout is an absolute joy to watch, and his last few steps--involving a staircase--brought a smile to my face just in their joyful energy.
  
  His singing style is a bit odd; he half-sings, half-recites (as someone put it, and I only couldn't think of the second word...) the lyrics to "his" songs--but apparently that's how Cohan himself did it. And perhaps it's what comes naturally to Cagney as well, considering he has a similar background as a poor Irishman who got his start in vaudeville, just like the real Cohan. We tend not to hear whole songs throughou the film though, as it's more about his life than about his musicals themselves, but we do see him go from being born all the way up through--well, let's not spoil it for those who don't know his history, but the reason FDR sends a message for him after he finishes performing a play as none other than FDR himself.
  
  The film bears what I consider a very 40s style to it, but considering the volume of 40s movies I've seen that are directed by Michael Curtiz, it may well be the Curtiz style that I'm speaking of instead (as this, too, was directed by Curtiz). Things feel as if they're still holding onto their theatrical roots, with more specific blocking and somewhat stiff acting that seems more focused on conveying lines and story than creating "characters." It also seems as if it still feels the freshness of the motion picture medium, with heavy, constant camera moves--though not distracting ones--and the feeling that they're almost still reeling from being able to make dialogue audible instead of typing it up on cards to insert between scenes. This gives movies like this a great feel, like they're still staring wide-eyed at the distant horizons and boundaries now re-set for motion pictures, as if they can now see so much more that they're able to do, but have yet to make use of much of that space and instead feel some comfort in drawing from what they're most familiar with. They feel so very honest and strong, the way even background characters speak in that rapid but clearly understandable way, as if they've all been doing this for years--which they probably have. It seems a lot more training was likely present in these actors than in those that would come in decades to follow, and while it contributes to that sort of awkwardness they seem to exhibit by being in a film set instead of on a stage, they feel more real in some ways despite that. I rather like it a lot, but it's not enough to save a bad movie. That's not the case here though, as it's quite snappy in dialogue, moves at a nicely brisk pace, has wonderful--and apparently historically accurate--set design for Cohan's plays, and is excellently performed by Cagney and the rest of the cast, including George Tobias as a grumpy and judgmental theatrical producer and Walter Huston (alas, the only two names I had even rough knowledge of) as Cohan's father Jerry (apparently actually "Jere" in reality).
  
  I guess I should go ahead and branch out into more Warner musicals, even if no one else's, huh?

  Share This Review
• 
  
  October 18, 2007

  hypathio7

  That gangster James Cagney can sing and dance!! I enjoyed this biopic very much especially for Cagney's against type performance. He is very talented.

  Share This Review
• 
  
  June 19, 2007

  garyX

  Not really my kind of thing, but Cagney really throws his all into the part of all-singing all-dancing George M. Cohan. But I'll stick to his gangster films, thank you very much.

  Share This Review
• 
  
  January 15, 2010

  luiser2gh

  James Cagney hace de todo y lo hace muy bien, YDD tiene buenos momentos y buenas escenas musicales en el teatro; es extremadamente estadunidense, hay USA por todos lados.-

  Share This Review
• 
  
  November 28, 2009

  jam233

  A wonderful classic, with James Cagney giving a very heartfelt and outstanding performance. Some outstanding song and dance numbers. Highly entertaining. Good direction. Jeanne Cagney gives her best performance.

  Share This Review
• 
  
  August 25, 2009

  razvascr

  truly an oscar performance by James Cagney !!

  Share This Review
• 
  
  August 25, 2009

  skilletfreak15

  rating this as a 3 because I haven't seen it in a really long time... probably more than 10 years

  Share This Review
• 
  
  August 22, 2009

  SageSlowdive

  One of the most pointless movies ever. Cagney DID NOT deserve the Oscar.

  Share This Review

View more Yankee Doodle Dandy reviews at RottenTomatoes.com

This board looks lonely. Be the first to talk about "Yankee Doodle Dandy" !

• Douglas Croft
• Eddie Foy Jr.
• Frances Langford
• George Barbier
• George Tobias
• Irene Manning
• James Cagney
• Jeanne Cagney
• Joan Leslie

Click a thumb to vote on that suggestion, or add your own suggestions.

• 
  The West Point Story (Fine and Dandy) (100%)
• 
  For Me And My Gal (33%)
• 
  White Heat (67%)

No facts approved yet. Be the first

• For which musical did James Cagney win the best actor Oscar?  Answer »
• Which actor in Yankee Doodle Dandy is heard to say quite often "My mother thanks you. My father thanks you. My sister thanks you. And I thank you"?  Answer »
• Name the movie from which this memorable quote comes... "My mother thanks you, my father thanks you, my sister thanks you, and I thank you."  Answer »
• Identify the film from this quote: "Oh, don't worry about the critics! You got a smash hit! It's in the air, kid! It's in the air! You can't stop anything that's in the air!"  Answer »

No quizzes for Yankee Doodle Dandy. Want to create one?

No video clips yet. Want to upload one?

• d0csdarlin
• LukardRa3000
• Jriff87
• saul195769
• radtazman
• Gogzilla
• axelh
• sneakypetegb

No recent headlines. Got one?

• 

  AFI Top 100 (1998)

  by aabbbiee
  100 Movies
• 

  Oscar Nominees: Best Picture

  by Agustin1986
  384 Movies
• 

  GOLDEN AGE OF CINEMA: Michael Curtiz

  by felix87
  55 Movies
• 

  AFI 100 Years, 100 Movies

  by acinca1
  100 Movies
• 

  Best Picture Nominees

  by kfthajer
  468 Movies

No skins yet. Interested in creating one?