Lindsay Lohan Keira Knightley Battle For Catherine...

If Lindsay is in it, I will stick to the Timothy Dalton Wuthering Heights movie. If they don't have the intelligence to put Keira in it, then how smart can the rest of the movie be?

Uh ... Lindsay Lohan as Catherine Earnshaw? I don't mind her, but she would never pull it off. Did you ever hear her put on a Brit accent? You don't want to.

I'd pick Keira Knightley - no question.

Are you kidding??? Why in hell would anyone pick Lindsay over Keira??? That's just dumb.

I know Lindsay has had her problems and is just trying to jump back on the horse, but she may need to find a different pony.

I think it's obvious who should play the part...KEIRA KNIGHTLEY HELLOOOO!!! she is much more better actress than Li-Lo

I vote for Keira Knightley.

i think Keira would do a much better job then Lindsay. Lindsays movies suck and i dont want a good classic book/movie to suck afterwards. Keria did a good job in Pride and Predjuice.

Pleasssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssse Don't LET LiLo NEAR this role!!!!!

well yes, i do agree that Lindsay would be a laughable material considering this subject.. i love both of them, and will be happy either to see if either of them played the movie. but i cant stand the nonsense and selfish comment regarding Lindsay, she have played diffrent role and want to be accepted as a versatile young actress same like her rival Keira or Scarlett.. i think she did good job in, Bobby, Praire home companion or even I knw who killed me.. the movie was a bomb, but she DID TRIED her best to play diffrent characters, right??
so why cant we accept and let her to..
if the girl want to change, let her no??

peace!

I agree with the comments below. Is it really that hard to choose between them. Keira is a far better actress than Lindsay.

UHM HELLO!!! KEIRA KNIGHTLEY IS OBVIOUSLY THE BEST CHOICE!!
lol i mean common she's already got the accent, and possibly the same characteristics!!

is it really that hard to pick between keira and lindsay??
i thought it would be obvious to go with keria

I'm sorry Lindsay Lohan? That is the most laughable thing I have read all day. I could see Keira doing it but like the article said she has been in a lot of period movies. What about someone new and fresh? I think that would be enjoyable (although I really like Keira). Oh who would be Heathcliff..? I will have to think about this.....