James Edmondson (toru771)

Superb, powerful film with great acting, particularly from Sean Penn (as expected) and Josh Brolin. Unfortunately, many of the supporting characters, and at times even Harvey Milk himself, seem to fall by the wayside.

The middle child in a very gifted family, and IMO, the best one of the three (except for what was done to Faramir's character).

Imagine for a moment how truly God-awful a film adaptation of LOTR could have been. Now, get on your unworthy knees and thank Peter Jackson for getting it right! Die-hard fans will want to spring for the extended edition.